PCM.daily banner
22-12-2024 18:16
PCM.daily
Users Online
· Guests Online: 34

· Members Online: 0

· Total Members: 162,196
· Newest Member: Santaelece
View Thread
PCM.daily » PCM.daily's Management Game » [Man-Game] Discussion
 Print Thread
2020-2021 Changes Discussion Thread
cunego59
Nemolito wrote:
An other thing is the testing you ask. Don't get me wrong, I would also like new ideas/other versions to be tested to know more about it. But to really have a good idea we'll need a lot of testing. Who will do this big amount of testing and report on it? Indeed, the reporters again. So that will definitely add to their "burden" as well. Also, I don't think a lot of reporters actually also have pcm 19/20 and/or 21 soon. So that burden will be on very few people then.

I don't think that burden would have to fall exclusively on reporters. We wouldn't need reports in the same way we do for races. Like, for sprints we would need a handful of screenshots from the last few kilometers at most. For other types of stages, even a few sentences of retelling may be enough. Or once certain patterns emerge, simply results in bulk to look at the distribution of rider results in a large sample size, so that we don't have to rely on anecdotal evidence for anything.

I think we could crowdsource a ton of testing, but like SotD said, we just have to start with that sooner rather than later if moving to another game is an actual possibility. Ulrich has already compiled a MG cdb that works for PCM20, iirc. But I guess we'd need a "go" from the Admins and then some sort of organisation, ideally in its own thread I think.
 
Ad Bot
Posted on 22-12-2024 18:16
Bot Agent

Posts: Countless
Joined: 23.11.09

IP: None  
SotD
Nemolito wrote:
That is the thing, I came here because there actually is so much evidence, just scroll through the results and look at the reports and you'll find tons of it. It's not that I'm just "feeling" like sth is wrong with the yellow jersey, but I'm also not going to spend time to make a spreadsheet or whatever to make sure it becomes even more clear - because it is. Like I said, anyone can check the reports Smile


In terms of coming better across to me the one adding a point is responsible for presenting the evidence to be honest. I did exactly what you asked, and came to the opposite conclusion. Like said, I only went through the PT, and there it doesn't seem like your suggestion is reasoned, so when I ask for some sort of evidence it would be much easier to "buy me over" if you wrote:

Take a look at race A, stage B, C and D. The same applies in Race Z, stage X and Y.

Otherwise it becomes every man for himself to justify their oppinion, and that isn't really helpful. As stated before I have seen no evidence of that represenation at PT level. In fact I can only conclude the opposite based on hardcore results, and reading through the final 5km.

I would love to see what happens at PCT or CT level, but must admit I don't really feel like tapping through various results in races I have slim to no knowledge about. In order to create a proper conclusion we need a full representation, and not just when it is going bad or good. If it occurs on 10-15 % of the time then it would be overkill to do anything (IMO), while if it happens 75% of the time we have to look into a feasible solution - if such a thing exist.


Nemolito wrote:
Also, I know in general sprinting AI sucks on this version, as I have already said multiple times. I am also not saying it is the only "problem" MG has to deal with. I am also not saying moving to another game is the (only) right option to solve this and/or other problems. I have only said that, if we decide to stick with pcm18, I had some possible solutions to the yellow jersey problem in flat stage races. I know this doesn't solve other problems such as trains being terrible, the DB being a bit too top-sprinter heavy, or any other problem, but it could be a solution to the yellow jersey problem, which is a very real and actual problem with pcm18 as well.


If the "yellow jersey curse" is actually a thing, and not "just" another burden of crappy sprints AI. Looking for the leader is often also something we tend to do more so, than the other riders. If a yellow jersey rider sprints from too far back, I don't see that as a worse thing than the 3 star favorite sprinting too early tbh. And before I can concluce that it actually have anything to do with leading the race I feel like it's really difficult for me to start negating on a possible solution.


Nemolito wrote:
I'm glad you're thinking about the reporters and the burden new changes would mean for them. I am obviously also thinking from that perspective, and I can tell you implementing the first solution I proposed (race the five stages apart and give the same bonus seconds in an excel file) seems very feasible to me and doesn't add that much burden to just creating the report(s) itself, that take so much more time. Honestly, that would be like one minute of excel work as soon as we have the right excel code(s), which I'm sure multiple people on here are able to give.


That's good to know - and if it really is a problem, and can be fixed by such extra workload I would think it's a great thing to implement. I can just see some added workload, not only in the spreadsheet, but also in the splitting up races, creating startlists for 5 races rather than 1 etc., so I can't believe it is something that can be done in a minute or so. But still, if it can be done in a decent timecost, then it's obviously a thumbs up.


Nemolito wrote:
An other thing is the testing you ask. Don't get me wrong, I would also like new ideas/other versions to be tested to know more about it. But to really have a good idea we'll need a lot of testing. Who will do this big amount of testing and report on it? Indeed, the reporters again. So that will definitely add to their "burden" as well. Also, I don't think a lot of reporters actually also have pcm 19/20 and/or 21 soon. So that burden will be on very few people then. Also, I've checked last year's discussion thread. Some guys did a lot of testing, with some very well explained results and thoughts. Things changed after that, but many problems stayed and even new ones came up such as the random gap after the first ten riders/sprinters forming and sometimes even causing time gaps.


True, but that is part of the game. Sometimes we move from one game to another, and before doing so we need testing and representation of facts. I fully aknowledge the fact that this takes time - but I don't need a lot of text to the results, rather a resultlist and some observations. Possibly a videotest or two where everyone can see what could be a new issue. Also this burden can be spread across the entire season (or 2/3 seasons). What seems to happen though is A) A lot of talk and B) Very late, and very little test and C) Implementation through some "last minute" voting.

Nemolito wrote:
I am not saying one of my solutions for the yellow jersey problem would mean sprinting will be just perfect. There will still be broken trains and top sprinters will probably not start performing like a half-god. But, a small change (like the first solution I proposed) could make sure that you know your rider won't just lose his lead in the GC because he is leading the GC, which is already a great thing imo.


I know, and I'm not implying that in order to defeat one problem, you have to defeat the remaining too. I would just like to have the necessary information on the problem (I have never heard of it before, and we are almost 2 seasons in) before talking solutions.
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2022/mghq.png
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2016/manager.png
pcmdaily.com/images/awards/2015/Manmanager.png
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2016/teamhq.png
 
baseballlover312
I have some time now, so I am checking the rouleur/sprinter theory. Will report back in a few. Smile
RIP Exxon Duke, David Veilleux, Double Feature, and Monster Energy
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2016/avatar.png
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2019/funniest.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2020/funniest.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2020/forumthread.png
i.imgur.com/VCXYUyF.png
i.imgur.com/4osUjkI.png
 
Nemolito
Ras Tailtean (C2):
Kip wins first stage, Cissé second. Kip then 18th in stage 2 after not caring, stage win goes to Andersen. In stage 3 Kragh Andersen, despite being the top favourite, simply doesn't care for the sprint. Same counts for nr2 and nr2 green jersey Kip

Tour of Eritrea (C2HC):
Coutinho wins stage 1. In stage 2 he doesn't care, but starts sprinting when it is way too late and leads the peloton behind the sprinting group, even losing a minute over 15 sprinters that got away.

Post Danmark Rundt (C2HC):
Mezgec wins stage 1, doesn't care in stage 2, finishing 19th.

Amissa Bongo (C2):
Te Brake wins stage 1, doesn't care in stage 2, finishing 11th. Reinhardt wins stage 2 and takes over GC, only to finish sixteenth in the next stage after, guess what, he didn't care about sprinting. Lobato del Valle wins the stage and takes over GC. In stage 4, he wasn't seen anywhere until the end, coming back from far away to remain in the lead with an 8th place. In the last stage, Lobato del Valle was nowhere to be seen in the whole sprint until the final shot, where he managed to be sixth after sprinting from very far away, wasn't enough to win the GC. Managers were actually happy to not be leading the GC before the final stage.

Literally any sprinting race/race with two stages being flat in C2 and C2HC this season, except for Tachira, where there were like 4 78 sprinters and the rest lower than 71.

Tour of Qatar (PT) last year:
Howard won stage 2 and took yellow after stage 1 was won by the breakaway without time difference to the pack. Howard gets destroyed in stage 3 after not caring, and when he finally starts caring it is too late and finishes 12th after a sprint from very far. Swift wins the stage and takes the GC. In the next stage, Swift is very far behind, but does manage a decent comeback to finish 10th and remain the GC lead. Swift does decent in the last (sprinter) stage then, not by position (10th) but by actually sprinting and even leading the peloton for a while.

I've seen many instances as well in the HC/C1 as well this season. Not going to search them all like I just did for C2/C2HC, but just two of the ones I reported on (mind you, I've reported on more such yellow jersey curse-stages, and seen a lot more):

Tour of Uppsala (C1):
Kemboi strong to win the prologue, but with his yellow jersey doesn't care to sprint in stage 2, finishes eleventh, also kind of leading the peloton behind the sprinter group.

Tour of Cyprus (HC):
Swift wins stage one and takes the GC. He's chilling in the middle of the pack with 4k to go and starts sprinting very late to finish tenth because he easily passes all the random 70-sprinters ahead of him. His supposed lead-out Kupfernagel doesn't even care about him and finishes third.

I'm not going to search for more examples like I said, even though there are way more. This is not just 15% either, but I guess that's clear already. Why I'm sure that it's a yellow jersey curse (except for, well, these obvious results that just keep coming)? In other races in later stages you can see a sprinter winning a stage and even taking green, and still doing well "normally" in the next stage. Things that come to mind that I've reported on are for example. I think Kump won two stages in a row in Pologne after being far enough behind in the GC and for example Itami was first followed by second in stage 3 and 4 of Cheshire after losing a lot of time in stage 1 on the cobbles.
www.pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2020/newmember.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2021/mgreporter21.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2022/mgtoty.png
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2023/moty-cunego.png
 
OlegTinkov
What I take out of this season so far is that when the teams that are favorite for the win have weak support the AI acts "strange", which is if you think about it good imo.

PCM is never going to be perfect and the Mangame makes it even harder for PCM AI. But in the end instead of trying to fix everything by micro management, I'm in the just deal with it, sometimes crazy results are fun team.

Every PCM is different some are better for sprinters, some are better for stage races etc. Of course it sucks when you focus your team on for example time trailing and it turns out the pcm version we are using sucks at it, I know all about it. But maybe next version you are on the lucky side again. At the end of the season the final rankings are overall pretty realistic when analyzing the teams.

Don't get me wrong if they are easy fixes for some problems I'm all in but just not overdo it is my advise. I have been enjoying the races/reports a lot this season: thanks to all the reporters! If they (the reporters) want to change things I will fully support that, they probably have the best overview anyways and also have more say in this imo.
 
http://www.pcmdaily.com/profile.php?lookup=6187
baseballlover312
Alright, so I did ten runs today across four different scenarios, 3 of the first 3, and then 1 crazy one just for fun at the end.

Parameters:

I used a stage from the 2017 Giro. Pan flat, but not edited to be completely straight and wide. Nevertheless, the streets were pretty wide and there weren't any super crazy turns which usually disrupted the trains.

i.imgur.com/NSfobto.jpg


I used the best of the best a CT field could possibly be for a flat race:
- Every CT team (Unless I missed one)
- Best 2 sprinters from each team
- Next 6 best flat riders

So obviously this is a really stacked startlist, more than any inflated DB startlist ever. But to be fair, it's not that much worse than a C2HC flat classic.

I used AKA as the primary subject of study because I know AKA and my team construction best, plus he is the guy that most people have considered when talking about the potential rouleur glitch. I also wanted to use CT so stats wouldn't be so high the daily form is capped at 85. His team featured Bertillson, Eislers, and De Vreese as his main helpers.

I kept the overlay on for a lot of screenshots so you can see who someone is or where exactly we are in the race.

Scenario 1: Completely normal stats

Scenario 2: AKA's Flat decreased to 73

Scenario 3: 77 Flat, but Spr/Acc changed from 81/77 to 79/79

Scenario 4: 77 Flat, 85/81 Spr/Acc

Scenario 1: Normal Stats


For reference, I'm including the startlist for each stage that the game generates. Doesn't seem to be any correlation with results, but it shows who the game thinks is good I guess.

i.imgur.com/nIbRIkc.jpg


Trial 1

i.imgur.com/CtsYezo.jpg


Break is caught and Strava/Carlsberg are the leading teams charging ahead at 15 km to go.

i.imgur.com/HsK46xy.jpg


Same teams, no trains yet, just over 5 km left to go.

i.imgur.com/y87C0uB.jpg


Naesen gets a gap suddenly. De Vreese is on the front. Nordica and Trans with trains.

i.imgur.com/1LJWgEt.jpg


Bertilsson leave a gap when he launches and AKA falls behind. Centovalli has Reinhardt, Scully, and Cisse, but they're nowhere to be seen.

i.imgur.com/TTGYcVA.jpg


Van der Sanden takes the win over Salleh and Carsi. AKA 5th, Bertilsson 8th. Reinhardt barely in top 10, Bouhanni 14th.

Results:
Spoiler
RankNameTeamTime
1Geert Van der SandenPhilips3h48'58
2Mohamed Harrif SallehTrans Cycling Teams.t.
3Mustafa CarsiNordica - Enels.t.
4Christian RanneriesTeam Europcars.t.
5Asbjorn Kragh AndersenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
6Rüdiger SeligBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
7Kristian SbaragliStravas.t.
8Christian BertilssonCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
9Wouter WippertBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
10Theo ReinhardtCentovalli - Fiats.t.
11Anthony LavoineCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
12Luke KeoughMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
13Marco GuillenLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
14Nacer BouhanniStravas.t.
15Dylan PageGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
16Greg Van AvermaetStravas.t.
17Lionel CoutinhoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
18Ismael KipGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
19Davide CimolaiEddie Stobarts.t.
20Oliver NaesenBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
21Sonny ColbrelliStravas.t.
22Daniel SchornTeam Europcars.t.
23Sonomtseren DelgerbayarBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
24Maciej UlanowskiNordica - Enels.t.
25Matteo PelucchiSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
26Vyacheslav KuznetsovStravas.t.
27Alain QuispeLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
28Jerome BaugniesLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
29Juan Jose Lobato del ValleSauber Petronas Racings.t.
30Janis DakterisCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
31Mikiel HabtomBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
32Sascha ModoloTrans Cycling Teams.t.
33Gasper KatrasnikGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
34Genki YamamotoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
35Mikhail IgnatievTrans Cycling Teams.t.
36Rudy BarbierGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
37William ConnollyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
38Kevin FeiereisenGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
39Benedikt MundleCentovalli - Fiats.t.
40Ben KingGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
41Alexey TsatevichCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
42Geraint ThomasTrans Cycling Teams.t.
43Sandis EislersCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
44Fabian LienhardCentovalli - Fiats.t.
45Luka MezgecTrans Cycling Teams.t.
46Davide MartinelliNordica - Enels.t.
47Jasper BovenhuisPhilipss.t.
48Tomas PaprstkaPhilipss.t.
49Romeo QuicibalLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
50Laurens De VreeseCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
51Daniel OssStravas.t.
52Juan Van HeerdenProject: Africas.t.
53Soufiane HaddiProject: Africas.t.
54Remco Te BrakeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
55Andre SteensenTrans Cycling Teams.t.
56Roger KlugeStravas.t.
57Suleiman KangangiGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
58Christopher Juul-JensenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
59Daniele RattoGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
60Michael SchwarzmannNordica - Enels.t.
61Nikolas MaesTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
62Erik Nordsaeter ResellCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
63Maris BogdanovicsEddie Stobarts.t.
64Zhihui JiangSauber Petronas Racings.t.
65Hakon Frengstad BergerEddie Stobarts.t.
66Bert Van LerberghePhilipss.t.
67Emil AnderssonEddie Stobarts.t.
68Fabien TaillefourEddie Stobarts.t.
69Travis MeyerEddie Stobarts.t.
70Adam Petrie-ArmstrongGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
71Pedro Merino CriadoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
72Robinson Steven RuizLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
73Thomas Vedel KvistTeam Europcars.t.
74Luka PibernikTrans Cycling Teams.t.
75Thanawut SanikwathiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
76Simone PetilliCampari Asahi Procyclings.t.
77Issiaka CisseCentovalli - Fiats.t.
78Ramon SinkeldamCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
79Gihan PushpakumaraEddie Stobarts.t.
80Jan GhyselinckCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
81Odd Christian EikingGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
82Jakob RatheMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
83Metkel KiflayProject: Africas.t.
84Tom ScullyCentovalli - Fiats.t.
85Thibaut PinotProject: Africas.t.
86Daniel ThorsenEddie Stobarts.t.
87Sascha WeberBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
88Jan OelerichStravas.t.
89Manuel StockerCentovalli - Fiats.t.
90Leonardo BassoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
91Nipuna Shira ManamalageNordica - Enels.t.
92Marco CanolaSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
93Carlos Alexandre ManarelliLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
94Maani AltanzulBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
95Sam BennettGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
96Arturs BelevicsCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
97Sean DowneyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
98Michel KrederPhilipss.t.
99Igor BoevPhilipss.t.
100Tesfay AbrahaTrans Cycling Teams.t.
101John-Lee AugustynProject: Africas.t.
102Simone ConsonniSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
103Mateo FrankovicMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
104Nicola BoemSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
105Faycal HamzaProject: Africas.t.
106Narankhuu BaterdeneBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
107Marc HirschiSauber Petronas Racings.t.
108Alexandros AgrotisNordica - Enels.t.
109Aksel NommelaTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
110Daniel HoelgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
111Pit SchlechterSauber Petronas Racings.t.
112Heiko RedeckerBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
113Nico KeinathPhilipss.t.
114Steele Von HoffBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
115Michael VinkTeam Europcars.t.
116Freddy CruzGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
117Jakub SkalaCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
118Andrea PaliniNordica - Enels.t.
119Alexander KriegerTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
120Baptiste PlanckaertCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
121Christoph TaubelGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
122Youcef ReguiguiProject: Africas.t.
123Jacques Janse van RensburgTeam Europcars.t.
124Noah GraniganMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
125Kilian FrankinySauber Petronas Racings.t.
126Manuel BetilsonProject: Africas.t.
127Ethan HayterLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
128Bilguunjargal ErdenebatBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
129Simon PellaudSauber Petronas Racings.t.
130Andrea PasqualonSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
131Martin MahdarTeam Europcars.t.
132Magnus Cort NielsenTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
133Samuel CoronelLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
134Carlo NoiaSauber Petronas Racings.t.
135James OramGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
136Aimiliano VilaNordica - Enels.t.
137Pavel KelemenBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
138Andrea Enrico MaccagliSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
139Dietmar Mehr-WenigeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
140Daniele Dall'OsteSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
141Steven KalfTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
142Tom DumoulinPhilipss.t.
143Martin WeissTeam Europcars.t.
144Luc WirtgenMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
145Felix EnglishGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
146Zeke MostovMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
147Kristjan KorenTeam Europcars.t.
148Houcaine El SabbahiBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
149Philip LindauGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
150Andreas KronTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
151Matic VeberSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
152Mathias NorsgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
153Tesfom OkbamariamBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
154Bob SchoonbroodtBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
155El Mehdi ChokriBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
156Brandon McNultyMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
157Mohamed Shawal Anuar AzizSauber Petronas Racings.t.
158Kristofer GunnlaugssonMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
159Wen Hao LiCarrefour - ESPN+ 2'42
160Olivier Le GacGuave's Sunlight Cycling+ 3'53
161Eoin McCarthyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.


Trial 2

i.imgur.com/JoMuDx8.jpg


Centovalli all over the front this time with Strava, Carlsberg nowhere to be seen.

i.imgur.com/Er87D5a.jpg


Sprint is on. Strava still in control, Reinhardt a bit in the wind. AKA well behind.

i.imgur.com/fDjLc3i.jpg


Reinhardt pulls through the middle to take the win. Van der Sanden the only guy to do well very well again in 2nd. Manarelli, Bouhanni and Lavoine in top 5. AKA fails to sprint and finishes 34th, behind his teammates.

Results:
Spoiler
RankNameTeamTime
1Theo ReinhardtCentovalli - Fiat3h44'51
2Geert Van der SandenPhilipss.t.
3Carlos Alexandre ManarelliLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
4Nacer BouhanniStravas.t.
5Anthony LavoineCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
6Mohamed Harrif SallehTrans Cycling Teams.t.
7Mustafa CarsiNordica - Enels.t.
8Genki YamamotoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
9Marco GuillenLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
10Sam BennettGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
11Wouter WippertBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
12Luka MezgecTrans Cycling Teams.t.
13Rüdiger SeligBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
14Ismael KipGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
15Sonny ColbrelliStravas.t.
16Sonomtseren DelgerbayarBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
17Sascha ModoloTrans Cycling Teams.t.
18Tom ScullyCentovalli - Fiats.t.
19Mikhail IgnatievTrans Cycling Teams.t.
20Daniel SchornTeam Europcars.t.
21Kristian SbaragliStravas.t.
22Jerome BaugniesLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
23Tesfay AbrahaTrans Cycling Teams.t.
24Gasper KatrasnikGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
25Ethan HayterLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
26Geraint ThomasTrans Cycling Teams.t.
27Issiaka CisseCentovalli - Fiats.t.
28Benedikt MundleCentovalli - Fiats.t.
29Christian BertilssonCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
30Mateo FrankovicMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
31Christian RanneriesTeam Europcars.t.
32Janis DakterisCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
33Sandis EislersCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
34Asbjorn Kragh AndersenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
35Matteo PelucchiSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
36Maris BogdanovicsEddie Stobarts.t.
37Alain QuispeLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
38Roger KlugeStravas.t.
39Christopher Juul-JensenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
40Juan Van HeerdenProject: Africas.t.
41Manuel StockerCentovalli - Fiats.t.
42Mikiel HabtomBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
43Juan Jose Lobato del ValleSauber Petronas Racings.t.
44Luke KeoughMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
45Nikolas MaesTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
46Soufiane HaddiProject: Africas.t.
47Travis MeyerEddie Stobarts.t.
48Tomas PaprstkaPhilipss.t.
49Oliver NaesenBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
50Igor BoevPhilipss.t.
51Andre SteensenTrans Cycling Teams.t.
52Davide CimolaiEddie Stobarts.t.
53Odd Christian EikingGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
54Emil AnderssonEddie Stobarts.t.
55Fabien TaillefourEddie Stobarts.t.
56Hakon Frengstad BergerEddie Stobarts.t.
57Jan GhyselinckCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
58Jasper BovenhuisPhilipss.t.
59Arturs BelevicsCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
60Nipuna Shira ManamalageNordica - Enels.t.
61Thanawut SanikwathiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
62Simone PetilliCampari Asahi Procyclings.t.
63Felix EnglishGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
64Zhihui JiangSauber Petronas Racings.t.
65Aimiliano VilaNordica - Enels.t.
66Gihan PushpakumaraEddie Stobarts.t.
67Heiko RedeckerBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
68Alexander KriegerTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
69Mathias NorsgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
70Philip LindauGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
71Thomas Vedel KvistTeam Europcars.t.
72Simone ConsonniSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
73Alexey TsatevichCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
74Nicola BoemSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
75William ConnollyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
76Daniel OssStravas.t.
77Marco CanolaSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
78Manuel BetilsonProject: Africas.t.
79Jakob RatheMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
80Vyacheslav KuznetsovStravas.t.
81Romeo QuicibalLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
82Andrea PasqualonSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
83Metkel KiflayProject: Africas.t.
84Erik Nordsaeter ResellCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
85Ramon SinkeldamCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
86Pit SchlechterSauber Petronas Racings.t.
87Tesfom OkbamariamBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
88Ben KingGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
89Baptiste PlanckaertCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
90Simon PellaudSauber Petronas Racings.t.
91Pavel KelemenBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
92Martin MahdarTeam Europcars.t.
93Remco Te BrakeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
94John-Lee AugustynProject: Africas.t.
95Zeke MostovMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
96Robinson Steven RuizLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
97Pedro Merino CriadoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
98Youcef ReguiguiProject: Africas.t.
99Noah GraniganMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
100Martin WeissTeam Europcars.t.
101Greg Van AvermaetStravas.t.
102Bob SchoonbroodtBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
103Kristofer GunnlaugssonMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
104Andrea PaliniNordica - Enels.t.
105Jan OelerichStravas.t.
106Thibaut PinotProject: Africas.t.
107Michael VinkTeam Europcars.t.
108Sascha WeberBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
109Andrea Enrico MaccagliSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
110Kilian FrankinySauber Petronas Racings.t.
111Jacques Janse van RensburgTeam Europcars.t.
112Bert Van LerberghePhilipss.t.
113Eoin McCarthyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
114Carlo NoiaSauber Petronas Racings.t.
115Daniele Dall'OsteSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
116Leonardo BassoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
117Maani AltanzulBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
118Houcaine El SabbahiBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
119Marc HirschiSauber Petronas Racings.t.
120Matic VeberSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
121Luc WirtgenMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
122Freddy CruzGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
123Sean DowneyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
124Fabian LienhardCentovalli - Fiats.t.
125El Mehdi ChokriBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
126Kristjan KorenTeam Europcars.t.
127Mohamed Shawal Anuar AzizSauber Petronas Racings.t.
128Brandon McNultyMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
129Michel KrederPhilipss.t.
130Tom DumoulinPhilipss.t.
131Jakub SkalaCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
132Maciej UlanowskiNordica - Enels.t.
133Davide MartinelliNordica - Enels.t.
134Wen Hao LiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
135Adam Petrie-ArmstrongGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
136Michael SchwarzmannNordica - Enels.t.
137Rudy BarbierGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
138Kevin FeiereisenGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
139Christoph TaubelGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
140Narankhuu BaterdeneBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
141Alexandros AgrotisNordica - Enels.t.
142Luka PibernikTrans Cycling Teams.t.
143Dietmar Mehr-WenigeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
144Suleiman KangangiGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
145Magnus Cort NielsenTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
146Nico KeinathPhilipss.t.
147Daniel HoelgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
148Steven KalfTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
149Daniele RattoGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
150Samuel CoronelLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
151Aksel NommelaTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
152Faycal HamzaProject: Africas.t.
153Dylan PageGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
154Andreas KronTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
155Daniel ThorsenEddie Stobarts.t.
156Steele Von HoffBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
157Olivier Le GacGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
158Lionel CoutinhoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
159Bilguunjargal ErdenebatBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
160James OramGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
161Laurens De VreeseCarlsberg - Danske Bank+ 5'31


Trial 3:

i.imgur.com/1BF7gqL.jpg


Little bit more chaotic this time, you can see the turn here in the final.

i.imgur.com/c4SvSdL.jpg


AKA is isolated and well behind the sprinter's teams.

i.imgur.com/rznzi5D.jpg


Bralirwa doing the main leadout. Carsi on the wheel.

i.imgur.com/S3h6l4q.jpg


Carsi takes a dominating win ahead of Selig and Lobato. AKA doesn't sprint and finishes 36th. Reinhardt also outside the top 10 this time, as Merino Craido finishes ahead of him.

i.imgur.com/YSzjWVo.jpg


Results:
Spoiler
RankNameTeamTime
1Mustafa CarsiNordica - Enel3h44'13
2Rüdiger SeligBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
3Juan Jose Lobato del ValleSauber Petronas Racings.t.
4Mohamed Harrif SallehTrans Cycling Teams.t.
5Nacer BouhanniStravas.t.
6Carlos Alexandre ManarelliLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
7Anthony LavoineCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
8Wouter WippertBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
9Pedro Merino CriadoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
10Luka MezgecTrans Cycling Teams.t.
11Theo ReinhardtCentovalli - Fiats.t.
12Davide CimolaiEddie Stobarts.t.
13Mikhail IgnatievTrans Cycling Teams.t.
14Sascha WeberBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
15Mikiel HabtomBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
16Alain QuispeLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
17Gasper KatrasnikGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
18Tom ScullyCentovalli - Fiats.t.
19Romeo QuicibalLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
20Geraint ThomasTrans Cycling Teams.t.
21Maris BogdanovicsEddie Stobarts.t.
22Maani AltanzulBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
23Pit SchlechterSauber Petronas Racings.t.
24Matteo PelucchiSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
25Genki YamamotoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
26Leonardo BassoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
27Issiaka CisseCentovalli - Fiats.t.
28Rudy BarbierGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
29Benedikt MundleCentovalli - Fiats.t.
30Maciej UlanowskiNordica - Enels.t.
31Jerome BaugniesLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
32Luke KeoughMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
33Heiko RedeckerBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
34Christian RanneriesTeam Europcars.t.
35Robinson Steven RuizLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
36Asbjorn Kragh AndersenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
37Alexander KriegerTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
38Oliver NaesenBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
39Christian BertilssonCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
40Christopher Juul-JensenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
41Daniel SchornTeam Europcars.t.
42Davide MartinelliNordica - Enels.t.
43Sonomtseren DelgerbayarBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
44Vyacheslav KuznetsovStravas.t.
45William ConnollyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
46Emil AnderssonEddie Stobarts.t.
47Magnus Cort NielsenTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
48Tomas PaprstkaPhilipss.t.
49Arturs BelevicsCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
50Travis MeyerEddie Stobarts.t.
51Tesfom OkbamariamBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
52Jasper BovenhuisPhilipss.t.
53Nikolas MaesTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
54Ben KingGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
55Soufiane HaddiProject: Africas.t.
56Sam BennettGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
57Juan Van HeerdenProject: Africas.t.
58Tom DumoulinPhilipss.t.
59Samuel CoronelLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
60Steele Von HoffBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
61Daniel ThorsenEddie Stobarts.t.
62Geert Van der SandenPhilipss.t.
63Sandis EislersCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
64Remco Te BrakeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
65Baptiste PlanckaertCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
66John-Lee AugustynProject: Africas.t.
67Thomas Vedel KvistTeam Europcars.t.
68Ismael KipGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
69Ramon SinkeldamCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
70Pavel KelemenBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
71Alexandros AgrotisNordica - Enels.t.
72Nipuna Shira ManamalageNordica - Enels.t.
73Daniel OssStravas.t.
74Bert Van LerberghePhilipss.t.
75Faycal HamzaProject: Africas.t.
76Martin MahdarTeam Europcars.t.
77Daniele RattoGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
78Jan GhyselinckCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
79Thibaut PinotProject: Africas.t.
80Dietmar Mehr-WenigeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
81Martin WeissTeam Europcars.t.
82Manuel BetilsonProject: Africas.t.
83Erik Nordsaeter ResellCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
84Jakob RatheMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
85Nicola BoemSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
86Mateo FrankovicMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
87Odd Christian EikingGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
88Andre SteensenTrans Cycling Teams.t.
89Suleiman KangangiGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
90Kristofer GunnlaugssonMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
91Marco CanolaSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
92Noah GraniganMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
93Luka PibernikTrans Cycling Teams.t.
94Wen Hao LiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
95Youcef ReguiguiProject: Africas.t.
96Adam Petrie-ArmstrongGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
97Laurens De VreeseCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
98Igor BoevPhilipss.t.
99Kevin FeiereisenGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
100Hakon Frengstad BergerEddie Stobarts.t.
101Michael VinkTeam Europcars.t.
102Philip LindauGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
103Jan OelerichStravas.t.
104Sascha ModoloTrans Cycling Teams.t.
105Nico KeinathPhilipss.t.
106Alexey TsatevichCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
107Simone ConsonniSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
108Aksel NommelaTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
109Michael SchwarzmannNordica - Enels.t.
110Narankhuu BaterdeneBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
111Andrea PaliniNordica - Enels.t.
112Bob SchoonbroodtBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
113Michel KrederPhilipss.t.
114Jacques Janse van RensburgTeam Europcars.t.
115Christoph TaubelGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
116Greg Van AvermaetStravas.t.
117Dylan PageGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
118Freddy CruzGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
119Sean DowneyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
120Jakub SkalaCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
121Marco GuillenLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
122Eoin McCarthyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
123Kristian SbaragliStravas.t.
124Daniele Dall'OsteSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
125Andrea Enrico MaccagliSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
126Felix EnglishGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
127Simon PellaudSauber Petronas Racings.t.
128Lionel CoutinhoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
129Daniel HoelgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
130Gihan PushpakumaraEddie Stobarts.t.
131Fabian LienhardCentovalli - Fiats.t.
132Manuel StockerCentovalli - Fiats.t.
133Bilguunjargal ErdenebatBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
134Olivier Le GacGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
135Roger KlugeStravas.t.
136Tesfay AbrahaTrans Cycling Teams.t.
137Aimiliano VilaNordica - Enels.t.
138James OramGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
139Kilian FrankinySauber Petronas Racings.t.
140Andreas KronTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
141El Mehdi ChokriBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
142Houcaine El SabbahiBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
143Ethan HayterLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
144Carlo NoiaSauber Petronas Racings.t.
145Andrea PasqualonSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
146Steven KalfTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
147Mathias NorsgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
148Matic VeberSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
149Brandon McNultyMcCormick Pro Cycling+ 3'19
150Luc WirtgenMcCormick Pro Cycling+ 3'56
151Mohamed Shawal Anuar AzizSauber Petronas Racings.t.
152Kristjan KorenTeam Europcars.t.
153Zhihui JiangSauber Petronas Racings.t.
154Fabien TaillefourEddie Stobarts.t.
155Thanawut SanikwathiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
156Janis DakterisCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
157Sonny ColbrelliStravas.t.
158Simone PetilliCampari Asahi Procycling+ 4'45
159Marc HirschiSauber Petronas Racings.t.
160Metkel KiflayProject: Africas.t.


Scenario 2: Decrease AKA's Flat from 77 -> 73


For the next 3 trials, I used the exact same startlist, except I decreased AKA's flat to 73. The point of this test was to see if making AKA's flat too weak to be a rouleur would have any effect. Would he now commit fully to the sprint?

i.imgur.com/tdRvfPP.jpg


Trial 1

i.imgur.com/0iKYpD3.jpg


Variety of teams controlling the race throughout the day.

i.imgur.com/NhmrhgI.jpg


AKA lingering near the front, no team support.

i.imgur.com/xmZO1gQ.jpg


No real trains, just very messy as the sprint opens.

i.imgur.com/rOsEV6w.jpg


AKA straight up sits up and starts talking on his radio during the sprint. :lol:

i.imgur.com/Illk4ru.jpg


Carsi takes another win, Bouhanni and Reinhardt behind.

i.imgur.com/F88hrrb.jpg


Kragh Andersen wins the sprint of people not involved in the sprint, 25th place.

Results
Spoiler
RankNameTeamTime
1Mustafa CarsiNordica - Enel3h52'22
2Nacer BouhanniStravas.t.
3Theo ReinhardtCentovalli - Fiats.t.
4Anthony LavoineCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
5Marco GuillenLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
6Rüdiger SeligBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
7Mohamed Harrif SallehTrans Cycling Teams.t.
8Rudy BarbierGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
9Alexander KriegerTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
10Jerome BaugniesLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
11Mikhail IgnatievTrans Cycling Teams.t.
12Nicola BoemSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
13Janis DakterisCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
14Wouter WippertBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
15Davide MartinelliNordica - Enels.t.
16Vyacheslav KuznetsovStravas.t.
17Sam BennettGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
18Luke KeoughMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
19Heiko RedeckerBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
20Maris BogdanovicsEddie Stobarts.t.
21Davide CimolaiEddie Stobarts.t.
22Sonomtseren DelgerbayarBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
23Pedro Merino CriadoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
24Benedikt MundleCentovalli - Fiats.t.
25Asbjorn Kragh AndersenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
26Nikolas MaesTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
27Thanawut SanikwathiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
28Tom ScullyCentovalli - Fiats.t.
29Oliver NaesenBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
30Maciej UlanowskiNordica - Enels.t.
31Christian RanneriesTeam Europcars.t.
32Ben KingGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
33Alain QuispeLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
34William ConnollyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
35Mikiel HabtomBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
36Christian BertilssonCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
37Juan Jose Lobato del ValleSauber Petronas Racings.t.
38Sandis EislersCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
39Robinson Steven RuizLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
40Juan Van HeerdenProject: Africas.t.
41Alexey TsatevichCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
42Thomas Vedel KvistTeam Europcars.t.
43Erik Nordsaeter ResellCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
44Christopher Juul-JensenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
45Emil AnderssonEddie Stobarts.t.
46Travis MeyerEddie Stobarts.t.
47Ramon SinkeldamCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
48Olivier Le GacGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
49Jasper BovenhuisPhilipss.t.
50Eoin McCarthyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
51Wen Hao LiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
52Gasper KatrasnikGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
53Manuel StockerCentovalli - Fiats.t.
54Soufiane HaddiProject: Africas.t.
55Daniel SchornTeam Europcars.t.
56Issiaka CisseCentovalli - Fiats.t.
57Jacques Janse van RensburgTeam Europcars.t.
58Thibaut PinotProject: Africas.t.
59Marc HirschiSauber Petronas Racings.t.
60Faycal HamzaProject: Africas.t.
61Daniel ThorsenEddie Stobarts.t.
62Samuel CoronelLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
63John-Lee AugustynProject: Africas.t.
64Zhihui JiangSauber Petronas Racings.t.
65Pit SchlechterSauber Petronas Racings.t.
66Jakob RatheMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
67Daniel HoelgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
68Baptiste PlanckaertCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
69Arturs BelevicsCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
70Mateo FrankovicMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
71Laurens De VreeseCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
72Michael VinkTeam Europcars.t.
73Simon PellaudSauber Petronas Racings.t.
74Kilian FrankinySauber Petronas Racings.t.
75Adam Petrie-ArmstrongGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
76Romeo QuicibalLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
77Carlo NoiaSauber Petronas Racings.t.
78Brandon McNultyMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
79Youcef ReguiguiProject: Africas.t.
80Tesfom OkbamariamBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
81Martin WeissTeam Europcars.t.
82Noah GraniganMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
83Kristjan KorenTeam Europcars.t.
84Kristofer GunnlaugssonMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
85Kristian SbaragliStravas.t.
86Manuel BetilsonProject: Africas.t.
87Zeke MostovMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
88Luc WirtgenMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
89Remco Te BrakeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
90Michel KrederPhilipss.t.
91Daniele RattoGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
92Greg Van AvermaetStravas.t.
93Carlos Alexandre ManarelliLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
94Suleiman KangangiGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
95Dietmar Mehr-WenigeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
96Odd Christian EikingGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
97Houcaine El SabbahiBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
98Martin MahdarTeam Europcars.t.
99Fabien TaillefourEddie Stobarts.t.
100Sonny ColbrelliStravas.t.
101Daniel OssStravas.t.
102Luka MezgecTrans Cycling Teams.t.
103Dylan PageGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
104Sascha ModoloTrans Cycling Teams.t.
105Jan OelerichStravas.t.
106Igor BoevPhilipss.t.
107Maani AltanzulBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
108Leonardo BassoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
109Geert Van der SandenPhilipss.t.
110Luka PibernikTrans Cycling Teams.t.
111Fabian LienhardCentovalli - Fiats.t.
112Andre SteensenTrans Cycling Teams.t.
113Nico KeinathPhilipss.t.
114Ethan HayterLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
115Philip LindauGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
116Sascha WeberBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
117Steele Von HoffBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
118Jakub SkalaCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
119Genki YamamotoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
120Nipuna Shira ManamalageNordica - Enels.t.
121Jan GhyselinckCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
122Bert Van LerberghePhilipss.t.
123Tomas PaprstkaPhilipss.t.
124Alexandros AgrotisNordica - Enels.t.
125Freddy CruzGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
126Hakon Frengstad BergerEddie Stobarts.t.
127James OramGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
128Metkel KiflayProject: Africas.t.
129Matteo PelucchiSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
130Tesfay AbrahaTrans Cycling Teams.t.
131Simone ConsonniSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
132Gihan PushpakumaraEddie Stobarts.t.
133Kevin FeiereisenGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
134Christoph TaubelGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
135Daniele Dall'OsteSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
136Geraint ThomasTrans Cycling Teams.t.
137Magnus Cort NielsenTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
138Andrea Enrico MaccagliSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
139Andrea PaliniNordica - Enels.t.
140Narankhuu BaterdeneBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
141Tom DumoulinPhilipss.t.
142Aksel NommelaTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
143Bob SchoonbroodtBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
144Matic VeberSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
145Bilguunjargal ErdenebatBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
146Aimiliano VilaNordica - Enels.t.
147Andreas KronTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
148Felix EnglishGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
149El Mehdi ChokriBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
150Sean DowneyGlanbia Foods Cycling Project+ 3'15
151Mohamed Shawal Anuar AzizSauber Petronas Racing+ 3'48
152Ismael KipGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
153Andrea PasqualonSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
154Pavel KelemenBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
155Marco CanolaSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
156Mathias NorsgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
157Lionel CoutinhoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
158Roger KlugeStravas.t.
159Michael SchwarzmannNordica - Enels.t.


Trial 2

i.imgur.com/ZegerGG.jpg


Agglomeration of Carlsberg and Centovalli guys near the front.

i.imgur.com/THacPjz.jpg


Bertilsson leading out AKA for once, Scully trying to leadout out Reinhardt. Both sprinters can't keep up with their leadouts at first.

i.imgur.com/DWWlMam.jpg


AKA manages to launch and looks good for a while, but fades hard and finishes 7th. Sam Bennett pips Reinhardt on the line.

Results:
Spoiler
RankNameTeamTime
1Sam BennettGlanbia Foods Cycling Project3h44'13
2Theo ReinhardtCentovalli - Fiats.t.
3Remco Te BrakeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
4Mohamed Harrif SallehTrans Cycling Teams.t.
5Dylan PageGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
6Anthony LavoineCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
7Asbjorn Kragh AndersenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
8Wouter WippertBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
9Mustafa CarsiNordica - Enels.t.
10Rüdiger SeligBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
11Mikiel HabtomBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
12Tom ScullyCentovalli - Fiats.t.
13Alexander KriegerTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
14Luke KeoughMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
15Luka MezgecTrans Cycling Teams.t.
16Christian BertilssonCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
17Sascha WeberBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
18Rudy BarbierGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
19Matteo PelucchiSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
20Jerome BaugniesLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
21Michel KrederPhilipss.t.
22Sascha ModoloTrans Cycling Teams.t.
23Hakon Frengstad BergerEddie Stobarts.t.
24Heiko RedeckerBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
25Juan Van HeerdenProject: Africas.t.
26Alain QuispeLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
27Bert Van LerberghePhilipss.t.
28Igor BoevPhilipss.t.
29Gasper KatrasnikGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
30Benedikt MundleCentovalli - Fiats.t.
31Maani AltanzulBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
32Mikhail IgnatievTrans Cycling Teams.t.
33Bob SchoonbroodtBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
34Jan GhyselinckCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
35Sonomtseren DelgerbayarBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
36Geraint ThomasTrans Cycling Teams.t.
37Leonardo BassoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
38Thomas Vedel KvistTeam Europcars.t.
39Nikolas MaesTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
40Geert Van der SandenPhilipss.t.
41William ConnollyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
42Fabian LienhardCentovalli - Fiats.t.
43Davide CimolaiEddie Stobarts.t.
44Soufiane HaddiProject: Africas.t.
45Oliver NaesenBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
46Travis MeyerEddie Stobarts.t.
47Ben KingGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
48Emil AnderssonEddie Stobarts.t.
49Nipuna Shira ManamalageNordica - Enels.t.
50Gihan PushpakumaraEddie Stobarts.t.
51Freddy CruzGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
52Jasper BovenhuisPhilipss.t.
53Andre SteensenTrans Cycling Teams.t.
54Bilguunjargal ErdenebatBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
55Tom DumoulinPhilipss.t.
56Issiaka CisseCentovalli - Fiats.t.
57Nacer BouhanniStravas.t.
58Juan Jose Lobato del ValleSauber Petronas Racings.t.
59Manuel StockerCentovalli - Fiats.t.
60Maris BogdanovicsEddie Stobarts.t.
61Kristian SbaragliStravas.t.
62Tomas PaprstkaPhilipss.t.
63Eoin McCarthyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
64Simone ConsonniSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
65Sonny ColbrelliStravas.t.
66Sandis EislersCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
67Jan OelerichStravas.t.
68Marco CanolaSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
69Ramon SinkeldamCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
70Zhihui JiangSauber Petronas Racings.t.
71Tesfom OkbamariamBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
72Pit SchlechterSauber Petronas Racings.t.
73Nicola BoemSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
74Felix EnglishGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
75Adam Petrie-ArmstrongGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
76Laurens De VreeseCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
77Roger KlugeStravas.t.
78John-Lee AugustynProject: Africas.t.
79Carlo NoiaSauber Petronas Racings.t.
80Vyacheslav KuznetsovStravas.t.
81Pedro Merino CriadoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
82Ismael KipGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
83Nico KeinathPhilipss.t.
84Narankhuu BaterdeneBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
85Marco GuillenLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
86Martin MahdarTeam Europcars.t.
87Pavel KelemenBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
88Faycal HamzaProject: Africas.t.
89Greg Van AvermaetStravas.t.
90Suleiman KangangiGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
91Thibaut PinotProject: Africas.t.
92Andrea PasqualonSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
93Marc HirschiSauber Petronas Racings.t.
94Jakub SkalaCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
95Daniel OssStravas.t.
96Daniele RattoGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
97Dietmar Mehr-WenigeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
98Christopher Juul-JensenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
99Manuel BetilsonProject: Africas.t.
100Mohamed Shawal Anuar AzizSauber Petronas Racings.t.
101Youcef ReguiguiProject: Africas.t.
102Janis DakterisCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
103Arturs BelevicsCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
104Baptiste PlanckaertCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
105Kilian FrankinySauber Petronas Racings.t.
106Christoph TaubelGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
107Lionel CoutinhoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
108Michael SchwarzmannNordica - Enels.t.
109Andrea Enrico MaccagliSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
110Metkel KiflayProject: Africas.t.
111Daniele Dall'OsteSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
112Christian RanneriesTeam Europcars.t.
113Daniel ThorsenEddie Stobarts.t.
114Thanawut SanikwathiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
115Mateo FrankovicMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
116Philip LindauGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
117Aksel NommelaTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
118Maciej UlanowskiNordica - Enels.t.
119Robinson Steven RuizLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
120Fabien TaillefourEddie Stobarts.t.
121Wen Hao LiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
122Olivier Le GacGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
123El Mehdi ChokriBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
124Luka PibernikTrans Cycling Teams.t.
125Carlos Alexandre ManarelliLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
126Andrea PaliniNordica - Enels.t.
127Daniel SchornTeam Europcars.t.
128Tesfay AbrahaTrans Cycling Teams.t.
129James OramGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
130Daniel HoelgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
131Erik Nordsaeter ResellCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
132Simon PellaudSauber Petronas Racings.t.
133Magnus Cort NielsenTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
134Michael VinkTeam Europcars.t.
135Ethan HayterLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
136Samuel CoronelLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
137Romeo QuicibalLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
138Alexey TsatevichCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
139Sean DowneyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
140Odd Christian EikingGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
141Davide MartinelliNordica - Enels.t.
142Matic VeberSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
143Steven KalfTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
144Andreas KronTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
145Jakob RatheMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
146Zeke MostovMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
147Kevin FeiereisenGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
148Aimiliano VilaNordica - Enels.t.
149Kristjan KorenTeam Europcars.t.
150Steele Von HoffBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
151Alexandros AgrotisNordica - Enels.t.
152Martin WeissTeam Europcars.t.
153Houcaine El SabbahiBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
154Noah GraniganMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
155Mathias NorsgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
156Jacques Janse van RensburgTeam Europcars.t.
157Genki YamamotoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
158Luc WirtgenMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
159Kristofer GunnlaugssonMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
160Brandon McNultyMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.


Trial 3:

i.imgur.com/0x3hsPz.jpg


Guave all over the front paceline for Coutinho.

i.imgur.com/OpHZm31.jpg


Centovalli with a very solid leadout, Tyrg too, but further behind.

i.imgur.com/0K5ASxX.jpg
i.imgur.com/Yn0jW57.jpg


AKA once again behind, no teammates. He starts his sprint late after a gap opens.

i.imgur.com/WFfEmqA.jpg


Krieger takes it over Lobato, and another great sprint by Carsi. Reinhardt switched sides of the rode and got slowed up. AKA in 28th.

Results:
Spoiler
RankNameTeamTime
1Alexander KriegerTryg - Ritter Sport3h41'35
2Juan Jose Lobato del ValleSauber Petronas Racings.t.
3Mustafa CarsiNordica - Enels.t.
4Anthony LavoineCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
5Lionel CoutinhoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
6Mikhail IgnatievTrans Cycling Teams.t.
7Theo ReinhardtCentovalli - Fiats.t.
8Luke KeoughMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
9Wouter WippertBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
10Nacer BouhanniStravas.t.
11Mohamed Harrif SallehTrans Cycling Teams.t.
12Rüdiger SeligBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
13Matteo PelucchiSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
14Gasper KatrasnikGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
15Tom ScullyCentovalli - Fiats.t.
16Thomas Vedel KvistTeam Europcars.t.
17Jerome BaugniesLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
18Benedikt MundleCentovalli - Fiats.t.
19Dylan PageGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
20Maris BogdanovicsEddie Stobarts.t.
21Sonomtseren DelgerbayarBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
22Kristian SbaragliStravas.t.
23Rudy BarbierGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
24Kevin FeiereisenGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
25Daniel SchornTeam Europcars.t.
26Issiaka CisseCentovalli - Fiats.t.
27Vyacheslav KuznetsovStravas.t.
28Asbjorn Kragh AndersenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
29Christian BertilssonCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
30Travis MeyerEddie Stobarts.t.
31Alain QuispeLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
32Greg Van AvermaetStravas.t.
33Christopher Juul-JensenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
34Davide CimolaiEddie Stobarts.t.
35Carlos Alexandre ManarelliLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
36Oliver NaesenBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
37Steven KalfTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
38Pit SchlechterSauber Petronas Racings.t.
39Geert Van der SandenPhilipss.t.
40Soufiane HaddiProject: Africas.t.
41John-Lee AugustynProject: Africas.t.
42Wen Hao LiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
43Michel KrederPhilipss.t.
44Ben KingGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
45Erik Nordsaeter ResellCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
46Magnus Cort NielsenTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
47Fabien TaillefourEddie Stobarts.t.
48Nikolas MaesTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
49Juan Van HeerdenProject: Africas.t.
50Daniel HoelgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
51Sandis EislersCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
52Igor BoevPhilipss.t.
53Ramon SinkeldamCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
54William ConnollyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
55Romeo QuicibalLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
56Aksel NommelaTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
57Gihan PushpakumaraEddie Stobarts.t.
58Andreas KronTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
59Manuel StockerCentovalli - Fiats.t.
60Sonny ColbrelliStravas.t.
61Sam BennettGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
62Thanawut SanikwathiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
63Baptiste PlanckaertCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
64Arturs BelevicsCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
65Felix EnglishGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
66Nico KeinathPhilipss.t.
67Adam Petrie-ArmstrongGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
68Bert Van LerberghePhilipss.t.
69Laurens De VreeseCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
70Hakon Frengstad BergerEddie Stobarts.t.
71Mateo FrankovicMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
72Tomas PaprstkaPhilipss.t.
73Daniel OssStravas.t.
74Jan OelerichStravas.t.
75Jan GhyselinckCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
76Faycal HamzaProject: Africas.t.
77Freddy CruzGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
78Thibaut PinotProject: Africas.t.
79Olivier Le GacGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
80Genki YamamotoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
81Nicola BoemSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
82Fabian LienhardCentovalli - Fiats.t.
83Noah GraniganMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
84Metkel KiflayProject: Africas.t.
85Eoin McCarthyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
86Jakub SkalaCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
87Zeke MostovMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
88Ethan HayterLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
89Sean DowneyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
90Michael VinkTeam Europcars.t.
91Jasper BovenhuisPhilipss.t.
92Tom DumoulinPhilipss.t.
93Mathias NorsgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
94Janis DakterisCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
95Suleiman KangangiGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
96Brandon McNultyMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
97Kristofer GunnlaugssonMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
98Maciej UlanowskiNordica - Enels.t.
99Roger KlugeStravas.t.
100Mikiel HabtomBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
101Luc WirtgenMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
102Youcef ReguiguiProject: Africas.t.
103Leonardo BassoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
104Martin WeissTeam Europcars.t.
105Christian RanneriesTeam Europcars.t.
106Odd Christian EikingGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
107Davide MartinelliNordica - Enels.t.
108Ismael KipGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
109Sascha WeberBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
110Pedro Merino CriadoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
111Samuel CoronelLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
112Remco Te BrakeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
113Daniele RattoGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
114Maani AltanzulBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
115Marco GuillenLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
116Alexey TsatevichCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
117Manuel BetilsonProject: Africas.t.
118Dietmar Mehr-WenigeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
119Nipuna Shira ManamalageNordica - Enels.t.
120Geraint ThomasTrans Cycling Teams.t.
121Narankhuu BaterdeneBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
122Robinson Steven RuizLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
123Tesfay AbrahaTrans Cycling Teams.t.
124Luka MezgecTrans Cycling Teams.t.
125Sascha ModoloTrans Cycling Teams.t.
126Heiko RedeckerBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
127Emil AnderssonEddie Stobarts.t.
128James OramGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
129Marco CanolaSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
130Simone ConsonniSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
131Philip LindauGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
132Andre SteensenTrans Cycling Teams.t.
133Luka PibernikTrans Cycling Teams.t.
134Zhihui JiangSauber Petronas Racings.t.
135Christoph TaubelGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
136Steele Von HoffBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
137Martin MahdarTeam Europcars.t.
138Pavel KelemenBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
139Marc HirschiSauber Petronas Racings.t.
140Tesfom OkbamariamBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
141Daniele Dall'OsteSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
142Simon PellaudSauber Petronas Racings.t.
143Jacques Janse van RensburgTeam Europcars.t.
144El Mehdi ChokriBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
145Bilguunjargal ErdenebatBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
146Aimiliano VilaNordica - Enels.t.
147Alexandros AgrotisNordica - Enels.t.
148Michael SchwarzmannNordica - Enels.t.
149Andrea Enrico MaccagliSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
150Andrea PaliniNordica - Enels.t.
151Carlo NoiaSauber Petronas Racings.t.
152Andrea PasqualonSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
153Mohamed Shawal Anuar AzizSauber Petronas Racings.t.
154Kilian FrankinySauber Petronas Racings.t.
155Houcaine El SabbahiBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
156Bob SchoonbroodtBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
157Kristjan KorenTeam Europcars.t.
158Matic VeberSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
159Daniel ThorsenEddie Stobart+ 3'42
160Jakob RatheMcCormick Pro Cycling+ 12'33

RIP Exxon Duke, David Veilleux, Double Feature, and Monster Energy
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2016/avatar.png
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2019/funniest.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2020/funniest.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2020/forumthread.png
i.imgur.com/VCXYUyF.png
i.imgur.com/4osUjkI.png
 
baseballlover312
Scenario 3: 77 Flat, but Spr/Acc is 79/79 instead of 81/77


Point of this test was to determine if rouleur designation and position is based not on flat stat, but on the ratio relationship between sprint and acceleration. In order to not make AKA too powerful, I decreased his Sprint parallel to increasing his acceleration. So in theory, if sprint > acc in effect, he should be weaker overall.

i.imgur.com/BER8aCJ.jpg


Trial 1:

i.imgur.com/xxyGu1p.jpg


Variety of teams pacing, but no Carlsberg.

i.imgur.com/Tljz0W2.jpg


Centovalli and Nordica looking good forming their trains behind the paceline.

i.imgur.com/bAXh13Z.jpg


Interestingly, it's Cisse, not Scully, doing the final leadout for Reinhardt this time. Ulanowski doing a great job for Carsi on the front. AKA at the back of this group.

i.imgur.com/bRdUzGe.jpg


Carsi takes another big win. He's really loving this stage. Some new names in the top place. AKA surfs wheels to finish 9th.

Result:
Spoiler
RankNameTeamTime
1Mustafa CarsiNordica - Enel3h41'31
2Luke KeoughMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
3Rüdiger SeligBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
4Rudy BarbierGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
5Theo ReinhardtCentovalli - Fiats.t.
6Wouter WippertBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
7Alexander KriegerTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
8Mohamed Harrif SallehTrans Cycling Teams.t.
9Asbjorn Kragh AndersenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
10Thomas Vedel KvistTeam Europcars.t.
11Anthony LavoineCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
12Mikiel HabtomBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
13Luka MezgecTrans Cycling Teams.t.
14Sam BennettGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
15Marco GuillenLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
16Nikolas MaesTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
17Issiaka CisseCentovalli - Fiats.t.
18Sonomtseren DelgerbayarBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
19Sascha ModoloTrans Cycling Teams.t.
20Christian BertilssonCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
21Matteo PelucchiSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
22Sonny ColbrelliStravas.t.
23Nacer BouhanniStravas.t.
24Maciej UlanowskiNordica - Enels.t.
25Davide CimolaiEddie Stobarts.t.
26William ConnollyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
27Alain QuispeLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
28Gasper KatrasnikGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
29Kristian SbaragliStravas.t.
30Vyacheslav KuznetsovStravas.t.
31Christopher Juul-JensenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
32Mikhail IgnatievTrans Cycling Teams.t.
33Laurens De VreeseCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
34Benedikt MundleCentovalli - Fiats.t.
35Jan OelerichStravas.t.
36Pedro Merino CriadoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
37Alexey TsatevichCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
38Jasper BovenhuisPhilipss.t.
39Soufiane HaddiProject: Africas.t.
40Juan Jose Lobato del ValleSauber Petronas Racings.t.
41Andre SteensenTrans Cycling Teams.t.
42Leonardo BassoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
43Tom ScullyCentovalli - Fiats.t.
44Sandis EislersCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
45Jakob RatheMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
46Jan GhyselinckCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
47Oliver NaesenBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
48Davide MartinelliNordica - Enels.t.
49Juan Van HeerdenProject: Africas.t.
50Manuel StockerCentovalli - Fiats.t.
51Sascha WeberBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
52Nipuna Shira ManamalageNordica - Enels.t.
53Hakon Frengstad BergerEddie Stobarts.t.
54Robinson Steven RuizLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
55Carlos Alexandre ManarelliLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
56Luka PibernikTrans Cycling Teams.t.
57Fabian LienhardCentovalli - Fiats.t.
58Michel KrederPhilipss.t.
59Tesfay AbrahaTrans Cycling Teams.t.
60Thanawut SanikwathiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
61Greg Van AvermaetStravas.t.
62Simone ConsonniSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
63Maris BogdanovicsEddie Stobarts.t.
64Sean DowneyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
65Zhihui JiangSauber Petronas Racings.t.
66Eoin McCarthyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
67Remco Te BrakeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
68Nicola BoemSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
69Tom DumoulinPhilipss.t.
70Andrea PasqualonSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
71Emil AnderssonEddie Stobarts.t.
72Michael SchwarzmannNordica - Enels.t.
73Fabien TaillefourEddie Stobarts.t.
74Marco CanolaSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
75Adam Petrie-ArmstrongGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
76Daniele RattoGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
77Geert Van der SandenPhilipss.t.
78Suleiman KangangiGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
79Daniel OssStravas.t.
80Travis MeyerEddie Stobarts.t.
81Pit SchlechterSauber Petronas Racings.t.
82Ben KingGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
83Maani AltanzulBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
84Bert Van LerberghePhilipss.t.
85Simon PellaudSauber Petronas Racings.t.
86Dietmar Mehr-WenigeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
87Gihan PushpakumaraEddie Stobarts.t.
88Marc HirschiSauber Petronas Racings.t.
89Ramon SinkeldamCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
90Steele Von HoffBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
91Samuel CoronelLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
92Wen Hao LiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
93Igor BoevPhilipss.t.
94Kilian FrankinySauber Petronas Racings.t.
95Matic VeberSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
96Daniel SchornTeam Europcars.t.
97Geraint ThomasTrans Cycling Teams.t.
98Ismael KipGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
99Jakub SkalaCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
100Michael VinkTeam Europcars.t.
101Genki YamamotoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
102Nico KeinathPhilipss.t.
103Philip LindauGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
104Freddy CruzGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
105Pavel KelemenBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
106Arturs BelevicsCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
107Thibaut PinotProject: Africas.t.
108Roger KlugeStravas.t.
109Mohamed Shawal Anuar AzizSauber Petronas Racings.t.
110Felix EnglishGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
111John-Lee AugustynProject: Africas.t.
112Tomas PaprstkaPhilipss.t.
113Christoph TaubelGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
114Baptiste PlanckaertCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
115Faycal HamzaProject: Africas.t.
116Romeo QuicibalLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
117Metkel KiflayProject: Africas.t.
118Jerome BaugniesLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
119Janis DakterisCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
120Youcef ReguiguiProject: Africas.t.
121Mateo FrankovicMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
122Jacques Janse van RensburgTeam Europcars.t.
123Lionel CoutinhoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
124Ethan HayterLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
125Heiko RedeckerBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
126Christian RanneriesTeam Europcars.t.
127Daniel HoelgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
128Olivier Le GacGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
129Andrea PaliniNordica - Enels.t.
130Alexandros AgrotisNordica - Enels.t.
131Magnus Cort NielsenTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
132Zeke MostovMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
133Daniele Dall'OsteSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
134Erik Nordsaeter ResellCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
135Kevin FeiereisenGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
136Noah GraniganMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
137Martin WeissTeam Europcars.t.
138Martin MahdarTeam Europcars.t.
139Andrea Enrico MaccagliSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
140Kristjan KorenTeam Europcars.t.
141Aksel NommelaTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
142Tesfom OkbamariamBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
143Dylan PageGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
144Mathias NorsgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
145Brandon McNultyMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
146Luc WirtgenMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
147Narankhuu BaterdeneBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
148El Mehdi ChokriBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
149Andreas KronTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
150Houcaine El SabbahiBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
151Bob SchoonbroodtBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
152James OramGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
153Kristofer GunnlaugssonMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
154Carlo NoiaSauber Petronas Racings.t.
155Steven KalfTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
156Aimiliano VilaNordica - Enels.t.
157Bilguunjargal ErdenebatBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
158Odd Christian EikingGjensidige Pro Cycling Team+ 3'33
159Daniel ThorsenEddie Stobart+ 5'01
160Manuel BetilsonProject: Africa+ 5'56


Trial 2:

i.imgur.com/nMW9kH7.jpg


Nordica with such a powerful leadout this time that he has actually forced a gap in the run in.

i.imgur.com/o8i2PVt.jpg


AKA again lets a gap go and starts late, he's way behind now.

i.imgur.com/srWZnUC.jpg


Carsi holds on for yet another victory. Reinhardt, who was uncharacteristically without a leadout this time, finishes second. AKA strolls in in 24th.

Results:
Spoiler
RankNameTeamTime
1Mustafa CarsiNordica - Enel3h55'13
2Theo ReinhardtCentovalli - Fiats.t.
3Dylan PageGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
4Nacer BouhanniStravas.t.
5Anthony LavoineCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
6Lionel CoutinhoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
7Luke KeoughMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
8Marco GuillenLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
9Wouter WippertBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
10Rüdiger SeligBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
11Mikhail IgnatievTrans Cycling Teams.t.
12Gasper KatrasnikGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
13Maciej UlanowskiNordica - Enels.t.
14Mohamed Harrif SallehTrans Cycling Teams.t.
15Sonomtseren DelgerbayarBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
16Ismael KipGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
17Janis DakterisCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
18Alexander KriegerTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
19Jerome BaugniesLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
20Thanawut SanikwathiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
21Vyacheslav KuznetsovStravas.t.
22Christian RanneriesTeam Europcars.t.
23Alain QuispeLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
24Asbjorn Kragh AndersenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
25Kevin FeiereisenGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
26Rudy BarbierGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
27Benedikt MundleCentovalli - Fiats.t.
28Maris BogdanovicsEddie Stobarts.t.
29Thomas Vedel KvistTeam Europcars.t.
30Travis MeyerEddie Stobarts.t.
31Soufiane HaddiProject: Africas.t.
32Hakon Frengstad BergerEddie Stobarts.t.
33Davide CimolaiEddie Stobarts.t.
34Jakub SkalaCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
35Pedro Merino CriadoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
36Mikiel HabtomBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
37Juan Jose Lobato del ValleSauber Petronas Racings.t.
38Alexey TsatevichCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
39Nikolas MaesTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
40Gihan PushpakumaraEddie Stobarts.t.
41Jan GhyselinckCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
42Christian BertilssonCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
43Oliver NaesenBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
44Ben KingGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
45Sam BennettGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
46Christopher Juul-JensenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
47Laurens De VreeseCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
48Nicola BoemSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
49Felix EnglishGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
50Matteo PelucchiSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
51William ConnollyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
52Davide MartinelliNordica - Enels.t.
53Ramon SinkeldamCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
54Olivier Le GacGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
55Erik Nordsaeter ResellCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
56Zhihui JiangSauber Petronas Racings.t.
57Daniel ThorsenEddie Stobarts.t.
58Geert Van der SandenPhilipss.t.
59Bert Van LerberghePhilipss.t.
60Emil AnderssonEddie Stobarts.t.
61Igor BoevPhilipss.t.
62Suleiman KangangiGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
63Nico KeinathPhilipss.t.
64Simone PetilliCampari Asahi Procyclings.t.
65Michel KrederPhilipss.t.
66Carlos Alexandre ManarelliLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
67Tom DumoulinPhilipss.t.
68Romeo QuicibalLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
69Kristian SbaragliStravas.t.
70Tomas PaprstkaPhilipss.t.
71Daniel SchornTeam Europcars.t.
72Jasper BovenhuisPhilipss.t.
73Sonny ColbrelliStravas.t.
74Tom ScullyCentovalli - Fiats.t.
75Baptiste PlanckaertCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
76Marco CanolaSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
77John-Lee AugustynProject: Africas.t.
78Dietmar Mehr-WenigeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
79Genki YamamotoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
80Juan Van HeerdenProject: Africas.t.
81Roger KlugeStravas.t.
82Martin WeissTeam Europcars.t.
83Maani AltanzulBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
84Martin MahdarTeam Europcars.t.
85Simone ConsonniSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
86Robinson Steven RuizLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
87Pit SchlechterSauber Petronas Racings.t.
88Thibaut PinotProject: Africas.t.
89Wen Hao LiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
90Daniele Dall'OsteSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
91Faycal HamzaProject: Africas.t.
92Odd Christian EikingGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
93Michael VinkTeam Europcars.t.
94Sascha WeberBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
95Metkel KiflayProject: Africas.t.
96Remco Te BrakeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
97Sandis EislersCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
98Daniel OssStravas.t.
99Daniele RattoGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
100Samuel CoronelLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
101Youcef ReguiguiProject: Africas.t.
102Jan OelerichStravas.t.
103Simon PellaudSauber Petronas Racings.t.
104Carlo NoiaSauber Petronas Racings.t.
105Greg Van AvermaetStravas.t.
106Manuel BetilsonProject: Africas.t.
107Marc HirschiSauber Petronas Racings.t.
108Michael SchwarzmannNordica - Enels.t.
109Christoph TaubelGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
110Sean DowneyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
111Jacques Janse van RensburgTeam Europcars.t.
112Fabian LienhardCentovalli - Fiats.t.
113Manuel StockerCentovalli - Fiats.t.
114Kilian FrankinySauber Petronas Racings.t.
115Leonardo BassoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
116Nipuna Shira ManamalageNordica - Enels.t.
117Ethan HayterLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
118Eoin McCarthyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
119Philip LindauGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
120Narankhuu BaterdeneBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
121Issiaka CisseCentovalli - Fiats.t.
122Magnus Cort NielsenTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
123Freddy CruzGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
124Andrea PaliniNordica - Enels.t.
125Luka PibernikTrans Cycling Teams.t.
126Luka MezgecTrans Cycling Teams.t.
127Aimiliano VilaNordica - Enels.t.
128Daniel HoelgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
129Pavel KelemenBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
130Alexandros AgrotisNordica - Enels.t.
131Steele Von HoffBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
132Andre SteensenTrans Cycling Teams.t.
133Andrea PasqualonSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
134Heiko RedeckerBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
135Jakob RatheMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
136Geraint ThomasTrans Cycling Teams.t.
137Fabien TaillefourEddie Stobarts.t.
138Andrea Enrico MaccagliSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
139Sascha ModoloTrans Cycling Teams.t.
140Aksel NommelaTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
141Noah GraniganMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
142Arturs BelevicsCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
143Adam Petrie-ArmstrongGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
144Mateo FrankovicMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
145Tesfay AbrahaTrans Cycling Teams.t.
146James OramGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
147Zeke MostovMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
148Tesfom OkbamariamBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
149Kristofer GunnlaugssonMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
150Houcaine El SabbahiBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
151Bilguunjargal ErdenebatBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
152Andreas KronTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
153Steven KalfTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
154Mathias NorsgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
155Bob SchoonbroodtBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
156El Mehdi ChokriBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
157Luc WirtgenMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
158Brandon McNultyMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
159Kristjan KorenTeam Europcars.t.
160Mohamed Shawal Anuar AzizSauber Petronas Racings.t.
161Matic VeberSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.


Trial 3:

i.imgur.com/Q7NkNPe.jpg


6 km to go and AKA is just sitting this one out. He's towards the back of the pack and not making any moves.

i.imgur.com/RjBrnnw.jpg


Messy sprint being led out by Bralirwa. Bertilsson is the Carlsberg rider. Seems he was the rider of choice this time.

i.imgur.com/OkTkFvB.jpg


Carsi sweeps this scenario with another victory over Keough and Lavoine. Reinhardt doesn't really try this time and gets 17th.

i.imgur.com/SgwO1xM.jpg


AKA doesn't even leave the saddle. 93rd place.

Results:
Spoiler
RankNameTeamTime
1Mustafa CarsiNordica - Enel3h43'19
2Luke KeoughMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
3Anthony LavoineCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
4Matteo PelucchiSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
5Rüdiger SeligBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
6Nacer BouhanniStravas.t.
7Mohamed Harrif SallehTrans Cycling Teams.t.
8Mikhail IgnatievTrans Cycling Teams.t.
9Wouter WippertBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
10Christian BertilssonCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
11Rudy BarbierGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
12Gasper KatrasnikGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
13Jerome BaugniesLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
14Soufiane HaddiProject: Africas.t.
15Hakon Frengstad BergerEddie Stobarts.t.
16Alain QuispeLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
17Theo ReinhardtCentovalli - Fiats.t.
18Sonomtseren DelgerbayarBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
19Juan Jose Lobato del ValleSauber Petronas Racings.t.
20Davide CimolaiEddie Stobarts.t.
21Benedikt MundleCentovalli - Fiats.t.
22Christian RanneriesTeam Europcars.t.
23Vyacheslav KuznetsovStravas.t.
24Janis DakterisCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
25Tom ScullyCentovalli - Fiats.t.
26Jakob RatheMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
27Nikolas MaesTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
28Oliver NaesenBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
29Sam BennettGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
30Pit SchlechterSauber Petronas Racings.t.
31Geert Van der SandenPhilipss.t.
32Maris BogdanovicsEddie Stobarts.t.
33Martin MahdarTeam Europcars.t.
34William ConnollyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
35Nicola BoemSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
36Daniel SchornTeam Europcars.t.
37Wen Hao LiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
38Michel KrederPhilipss.t.
39Travis MeyerEddie Stobarts.t.
40Emil AnderssonEddie Stobarts.t.
41Christopher Juul-JensenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
42Bert Van LerberghePhilipss.t.
43Ben KingGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
44Jakub SkalaCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
45Mateo FrankovicMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
46Baptiste PlanckaertCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
47Michael VinkTeam Europcars.t.
48Alexey TsatevichCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
49Igor BoevPhilipss.t.
50Jasper BovenhuisPhilipss.t.
51Kristofer GunnlaugssonMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
52Manuel StockerCentovalli - Fiats.t.
53Jan GhyselinckCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
54Zeke MostovMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
55Fabien TaillefourEddie Stobarts.t.
56Sean DowneyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
57Carlos Alexandre ManarelliLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
58Sandis EislersCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
59Juan Van HeerdenProject: Africas.t.
60Gihan PushpakumaraEddie Stobarts.t.
61Faycal HamzaProject: Africas.t.
62Tomas PaprstkaPhilipss.t.
63Thibaut PinotProject: Africas.t.
64John-Lee AugustynProject: Africas.t.
65Mathias NorsgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
66Fabian LienhardCentovalli - Fiats.t.
67Issiaka CisseCentovalli - Fiats.t.
68Romeo QuicibalLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
69Thanawut SanikwathiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
70Felix EnglishGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
71Leonardo BassoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
72Alexander KriegerTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
73Youcef ReguiguiProject: Africas.t.
74Roger KlugeStravas.t.
75Kristian SbaragliStravas.t.
76Thomas Vedel KvistTeam Europcars.t.
77Daniel OssStravas.t.
78Adam Petrie-ArmstrongGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
79Arturs BelevicsCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
80Zhihui JiangSauber Petronas Racings.t.
81Remco Te BrakeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
82Marc HirschiSauber Petronas Racings.t.
83Ramon SinkeldamCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
84Kilian FrankinySauber Petronas Racings.t.
85Ismael KipGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
86Laurens De VreeseCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
87Freddy CruzGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
88Jan OelerichStravas.t.
89Robinson Steven RuizLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
90Sascha ModoloTrans Cycling Teams.t.
91Carlo NoiaSauber Petronas Racings.t.
92Philip LindauGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
93Asbjorn Kragh AndersenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
94Nico KeinathPhilipss.t.
95Lionel CoutinhoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
96Daniel HoelgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
97Aksel NommelaTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
98Manuel BetilsonProject: Africas.t.
99Mohamed Shawal Anuar AzizSauber Petronas Racings.t.
100Odd Christian EikingGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
101Suleiman KangangiGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
102Kevin FeiereisenGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
103Dietmar Mehr-WenigeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
104Olivier Le GacGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
105Eoin McCarthyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
106Samuel CoronelLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
107Luka PibernikTrans Cycling Teams.t.
108Genki YamamotoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
109Maani AltanzulBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
110Steele Von HoffBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
111Luka MezgecTrans Cycling Teams.t.
112Maciej UlanowskiNordica - Enels.t.
113Pedro Merino CriadoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
114Sascha WeberBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
115Daniele RattoGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
116Luc WirtgenMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
117Simon PellaudSauber Petronas Racings.t.
118Davide MartinelliNordica - Enels.t.
119Sonny ColbrelliStravas.t.
120Marco GuillenLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
121Metkel KiflayProject: Africas.t.
122Heiko RedeckerBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
123Ethan HayterLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
124James OramGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
125Greg Van AvermaetStravas.t.
126Brandon McNultyMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
127Mikiel HabtomBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
128Dylan PageGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
129Tesfay AbrahaTrans Cycling Teams.t.
130Martin WeissTeam Europcars.t.
131Bilguunjargal ErdenebatBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
132Andrea Enrico MaccagliSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
133Noah GraniganMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
134Nipuna Shira ManamalageNordica - Enels.t.
135Narankhuu BaterdeneBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
136Tesfom OkbamariamBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
137Geraint ThomasTrans Cycling Teams.t.
138Alexandros AgrotisNordica - Enels.t.
139Marco CanolaSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
140Andrea PaliniNordica - Enels.t.
141Bob SchoonbroodtBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
142Magnus Cort NielsenTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
143Michael SchwarzmannNordica - Enels.t.
144Erik Nordsaeter ResellCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
145Aimiliano VilaNordica - Enels.t.
146Steven KalfTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
147Pavel KelemenBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
148El Mehdi ChokriBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
149Andreas KronTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
150Daniele Dall'OsteSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
151Christoph TaubelGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
152Kristjan KorenTeam Europcars.t.
153Daniel ThorsenEddie Stobarts.t.
154Simone ConsonniSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
155Jacques Janse van RensburgTeam Europcars.t.
156Houcaine El SabbahiBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
157Andrea PasqualonSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
158Andre SteensenTrans Cycling Teams.t.
159Tom DumoulinPhilipss.t.
160Matic VeberSotto il sole di Riccione+ 4'28
161Simone PetilliCampari Asahi Procycling+ 6'43


Scenario 4: AKA at 85/81 Spr/Acc


At this point I just wanted to have some fun. I wondered what would happen if we put AKA at normal stats, then increased both his spr/acc by 4 to max out his sprint. So same difference as usual, but absolutely dwarfing stats of all competitors.

i.imgur.com/roBZwpy.jpg


AKA listed as the best rider for the first time.

i.imgur.com/mCYu1jt.jpg


Carlsberg and Guave are the top teams in terms of numbers nearing 5 km left.

i.imgur.com/QhwM8lN.jpg


Guave, Carlsberg, and Bralirwa all set up cleanly to start the sprint.

i.imgur.com/rUlKh9M.jpg


Everyone launches around the same time, and it's just a normal drag race. A bunch of guys swarm AKA, but he's able to win by half a bike length. Carsi finally humbled, finishing 8th.

Result:
Spoiler
RankNameTeamTime
1Asbjorn Kragh AndersenCarlsberg - Danske Bank3h49'35
2Matteo PelucchiSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
3Rüdiger SeligBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
4Lionel CoutinhoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
5Luke KeoughMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
6Theo ReinhardtCentovalli - Fiats.t.
7Mohamed Harrif SallehTrans Cycling Teams.t.
8Mustafa CarsiNordica - Enels.t.
9Nacer BouhanniStravas.t.
10Heiko RedeckerBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
11Marco GuillenLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
12Christian BertilssonCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
13Genki YamamotoGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
14Geert Van der SandenPhilipss.t.
15William ConnollyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
16Alain QuispeLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
17Gasper KatrasnikGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
18Mikhail IgnatievTrans Cycling Teams.t.
19Benedikt MundleCentovalli - Fiats.t.
20Nikolas MaesTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
21Wouter WippertBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
22Sonomtseren DelgerbayarBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
23Dylan PageGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
24Sandis EislersCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
25Christian RanneriesTeam Europcars.t.
26Travis MeyerEddie Stobarts.t.
27Mikiel HabtomBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
28Oliver NaesenBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
29Tomas PaprstkaPhilipss.t.
30Gihan PushpakumaraEddie Stobarts.t.
31Jerome BaugniesLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
32Kevin FeiereisenGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
33Anthony LavoineCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
34Maris BogdanovicsEddie Stobarts.t.
35Alexander KriegerTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
36Juan Jose Lobato del ValleSauber Petronas Racings.t.
37Adam Petrie-ArmstrongGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
38Davide CimolaiEddie Stobarts.t.
39Vyacheslav KuznetsovStravas.t.
40Christopher Juul-JensenCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
41Laurens De VreeseCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
42Jan GhyselinckCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
43Jasper BovenhuisPhilipss.t.
44Ben KingGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
45James OramGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
46Wen Hao LiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
47Tesfom OkbamariamBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
48Bert Van LerberghePhilipss.t.
49Sean DowneyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
50Aimiliano VilaNordica - Enels.t.
51Rudy BarbierGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
52Nipuna Shira ManamalageNordica - Enels.t.
53Ramon SinkeldamCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
54Eoin McCarthyGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
55Zeke MostovMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
56Robinson Steven RuizLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
57Michel KrederPhilipss.t.
58Daniel ThorsenEddie Stobarts.t.
59Tom ScullyCentovalli - Fiats.t.
60Hakon Frengstad BergerEddie Stobarts.t.
61Daniel SchornTeam Europcars.t.
62Soufiane HaddiProject: Africas.t.
63Thomas Vedel KvistTeam Europcars.t.
64Fabien TaillefourEddie Stobarts.t.
65Kristjan KorenTeam Europcars.t.
66Juan Van HeerdenProject: Africas.t.
67Erik Nordsaeter ResellCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
68Zhihui JiangSauber Petronas Racings.t.
69Odd Christian EikingGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
70Pit SchlechterSauber Petronas Racings.t.
71Issiaka CisseCentovalli - Fiats.t.
72Olivier Le GacGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
73Simon PellaudSauber Petronas Racings.t.
74Thibaut PinotProject: Africas.t.
75Sam BennettGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
76Andrea PaliniNordica - Enels.t.
77Metkel KiflayProject: Africas.t.
78Emil AnderssonEddie Stobarts.t.
79Ethan HayterLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
80Faycal HamzaProject: Africas.t.
81Dietmar Mehr-WenigeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
82Youcef ReguiguiProject: Africas.t.
83John-Lee AugustynProject: Africas.t.
84Sascha WeberBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
85Romeo QuicibalLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
86Sascha ModoloTrans Cycling Teams.t.
87Arturs BelevicsCarlsberg - Danske Banks.t.
88Kilian FrankinySauber Petronas Racings.t.
89Kristian SbaragliStravas.t.
90Christoph TaubelGuave's Sunlight Cyclings.t.
91Mohamed Shawal Anuar AzizSauber Petronas Racings.t.
92Daniele RattoGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
93Simone ConsonniSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
94Suleiman KangangiGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
95Roger KlugeStravas.t.
96Nicola BoemSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
97Remco Te BrakeGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
98Daniel OssStravas.t.
99Pedro Merino CriadoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
100Jakub SkalaCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
101Michael SchwarzmannNordica - Enels.t.
102Greg Van AvermaetStravas.t.
103Manuel StockerCentovalli - Fiats.t.
104Igor BoevPhilipss.t.
105Andre SteensenTrans Cycling Teams.t.
106Carlos Alexandre ManarelliLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
107Maani AltanzulBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
108Nico KeinathPhilipss.t.
109Manuel BetilsonProject: Africas.t.
110Davide MartinelliNordica - Enels.t.
111Jan OelerichStravas.t.
112Maciej UlanowskiNordica - Enels.t.
113Tom DumoulinPhilipss.t.
114Ismael KipGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
115Felix EnglishGlanbia Foods Cycling Projects.t.
116Philip LindauGjensidige Pro Cycling Teams.t.
117Geraint ThomasTrans Cycling Teams.t.
118Sonny ColbrelliStravas.t.
119Alexandros AgrotisNordica - Enels.t.
120Daniel HoelgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
121Pavel KelemenBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
122Aksel NommelaTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
123Luka MezgecTrans Cycling Teams.t.
124Marco CanolaSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
125Luka PibernikTrans Cycling Teams.t.
126Samuel CoronelLos Pollos Hermanoss.t.
127Bilguunjargal ErdenebatBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
128Magnus Cort NielsenTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
129Marc HirschiSauber Petronas Racings.t.
130Daniele Dall'OsteSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
131Tesfay AbrahaTrans Cycling Teams.t.
132Steele Von HoffBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
133Jakob RatheMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
134El Mehdi ChokriBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
135Narankhuu BaterdeneBNZ Cycling Teams.t.
136Houcaine El SabbahiBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
137Martin MahdarTeam Europcars.t.
138Leonardo BassoCentovalli - Fiats.t.
139Martin WeissTeam Europcars.t.
140Fabian LienhardCentovalli - Fiats.t.
141Andreas KronTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
142Bob SchoonbroodtBralirwa - Stevens Bikess.t.
143Jacques Janse van RensburgTeam Europcars.t.
144Andrea PasqualonSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
145Mathias NorsgaardTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
146Steven KalfTryg - Ritter Sports.t.
147Luc WirtgenMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
148Michael VinkTeam Europcars.t.
149Brandon McNultyMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
150Andrea Enrico MaccagliSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
151Noah GraniganMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
152Kristofer GunnlaugssonMcCormick Pro Cyclings.t.
153Matic VeberSotto il sole di Ricciones.t.
154Baptiste PlanckaertCarrefour - ESPN+ 3'31
155Thanawut SanikwathiCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
156Alexey TsatevichCarrefour - ESPN+ 4'42
157Carlo NoiaSauber Petronas Racing+ 5'15
158Mateo FrankovicMcCormick Pro Cycling+ 5'49
159Janis DakterisCarrefour - ESPNs.t.
160Simone PetilliCampari Asahi Procycling+ 6'33
161Freddy CruzGlanbia Foods Cycling Project+ 11'19


Conclusions


So I guess these trials prove that there's no cookie cutter role preventing guys like AKA or Ingus Eislers from sprinting all the time, at least based on the ratios of their flat, sprint, and acceleration. The results in all 3 scenarios were very similar for AKA. Minor placings in one trial, but doesn't compete at all in the other two. Stat changes seemed to have little to no effect on the outcome.

In 9 trials, AKA had one top 5 in the very first race, and two lower top 10's. Other than that, he was outside the top 20 every time. Reinhardt was pretty routinely in the top 5-10. Carsi absolutely dominated for the most part, and other guys rotated through the top 5.

At this point then, I guess the only thing I discovered is that there's just no way to salvage a guy like AKA at this point. The game doesn't like him, regardless of his main stat makeup. High acceleration guys generally seem to be prioritized, but having equal sprint and acceleration alone does not make him act as a real sprinter.

On the bright side, some leadouts did work well, though surprising often with several riders lacking in stats like resistance.
Edited by baseballlover312 on 12-04-2021 19:30
 
valverde321
Just wondering something here but if you tried to start a career with the MG DB, I think the team selection screen usually says what rider type a rider has. I dont think MG db sets these, so the type that comes up automatically may show what type he's seen as. If its indeed barouder, then perhaps that is the issue.

Could you try experiments where AKA is set as a sprinter (definitively) in the db for test purposes and see if that changes anything?

I think being able to set our "climbers" as "stage racers" and barouders as "sprinters" in the off-season may actually help some of our issues, although its pure speculation at this point.
 
baseballlover312
valverde321 wrote:
Just wondering something here but if you tried to start a career with the MG DB, I think the team selection screen usually says what rider type a rider has. I dont think MG db sets these, so the type that comes up automatically may show what type he's seen as. If its indeed barouder, then perhaps that is the issue.

Could you try experiments where AKA is set as a sprinter (definitively) in the db for test purposes and see if that changes anything?

I think being able to set our "climbers" as "stage racers" and barouders as "sprinters" in the off-season may actually help some of our issues, although its pure speculation at this point.


Just tried this. AKA is indeed judged to be a sprinter by PCM, although there were some other interesting distinctions (e.g. Warbasse as a climber, not stage racer).
RIP Exxon Duke, David Veilleux, Double Feature, and Monster Energy
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2016/avatar.png
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2019/funniest.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2020/funniest.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2020/forumthread.png
i.imgur.com/VCXYUyF.png
i.imgur.com/4osUjkI.png
 
Ulrich Ulriksen
So a few thoughts:

@SotD - I report mostly on PT but obviously follow CT so I have a pretty good view on both. I think Pro Tour spints are better and less weird because (1) there are far less sprinters and their stats are more spread and (2) There aren't that many sprinter only GC races. So I think if you only follow mostly PT you get a somewhat rosier view.

@nemolito - like your one stage at a time idea and agree it wouldn't be a big deal and should fix the problem. Don't love the other idea. We probably shouldn't call it the Yellow Jersey curse as that does make it sound like a meme. Perhaps "Riding as GC rider" problem, although that is a mouthful. Also really agree there should be no KOM or reduced KOM points in the sprint focused races, feels like undeserved points given at random.

@bbl - my diagnosis:

Trial 1: AKA rides as rouler with Bertillsson as sprinter. In at least one trial Bertilsson gets a top 10, but mostly he isn't good enough so he doesn't get results. Keough has similar outcomes - some top tens and some no shows.

Trial 2: AKA is now your sprinter. But ACC matters to the game, So he isn't a very good sprinter, in game terms, so in a stacked field he doesn't sprint. In the actual Ras neither Keough or Bennet or Reinhardt sprinted once so not surprised he doesn't sprint in this field with those stats. I think the game sees an 81/77 sprinter as similar to an 77/81 sprinter whereas Mangame players tend to view the former as much better than the latter. I think the game views them both as 79ish and in this field those guys only get to sprint occasionally.


Trial 3: AKA is back to being a rouleur with Bertilssion as sprinter (he gets 1 top 10).

Trial 4: His sprint stats are now good enough to get him treated as a sprinter.

So I think you're right that designation as a rouluer depends on a combination of FL/RS/ST/SP/AC - I believe it also looks at the presence of other riders. I would be interested in Trial 3 with AKA and nobody else anything like a sprinter in your team. To see if he sprints (leadout will be bad). If he does at least we know that if you avoid getting a rider on your team who could be the sprinter the potential rouler will be treated as a sprinter (assuming he qualifies as one)

Another alternative would be run the test with only 5-8 teams with sprinters and fill the rest with generic riders - recognize this would require a lot more work to generate. But this would separate the rouleur problem from the too many sprinters problem.

The game definitely values ACC to some degree, I correlated last years results with stats and came up about 70/30 SP and ACC before considering other stats.

Also, Stamina definitely matters in the selection of a rouler even if the race is 100k.
Which is why Vanbilsen attacks while Bonifazio does nothing. My suspicion is Bonifazio isn't good enough to sprint when you have a leading rouleur, as the team backs the rouler instead. Although not sure the cut point - in the TDF Van der Lijke still sprinted although Holloway rode as a rouleur. But this may vary in tours versus classics.
Man Game: McCormick Pro Cycling
 
redordead
I agree mostly with what Ulrich wrote. Also I think there is a clear distinction with how the AI handles sprints in a stage race and in a one day race.

If the rouleur role is given to a rider in a stage race, I can hardly remember to see that rider perform late attacks. So he is pretty much useless in sprinter stage races. Why that rider wouldn't be used as a leadout instead? I suspect that the rouleur is either favoured or on equal footing to a sprinter and therefore just rides his own race. Which means he does nothing in this case.

Meanwhile in one day races late attacks come from riders that I imagine get the rouleur role, they attack quite frequently. They position themselves similar to sprinters and either attack or simply sprint like others. In my observation of my own team in these races, I've had 2 sprinters Boeckmans and Saber. On two occasions Saber was in the rouleur role and the other time he was a leadout man. So the 80/82 rider takes prioritity over the 81/79 rider, meaning that ACC is a very important stat. It also shows that the double leadership between a rouleur and sprinter can work. One attacks and the other sprints. But only one day races seem to allow these late attacks.

On the ACC point, a great example is Reinhardt. He has only 79 spr, but has been performing like a top 5 sprinter this year, against PCT competition. I'm not sure any other 79 sprinter has done much in those stacked fields, but with 84 ACC he probably get treated like an 81/82 rider, which would make him one of the best in PCT. While ACC I think has shown to be a very important stat for sprinting, the AI also seems to weigh it quite heavily when detemining who gets sprinting priority.

But like I mentioned in one of my previous posts where I detailed the lopsided scoring of sprinters in the PCT this year. When the startlist is overflowing with quality sprinters in most races, the results will end up being even more random than they should be.

pcmdaily.com/images/mg/PCMdailyAwards2018/mgnewmanager.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2020/mghq2.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2021/mgmanager21.png


"I am a cyclist, I may not be the best, but that is what I strive to be. I may never get there, but I will never quit trying." - Tadej Pogačar
 
SotD
Thanks for the elaboration Nemolito and Ulrich. That's more something even I can understand Wink

If it really isn't a big issue to cut the stages then that seems like a very smart way about it. But isn't the flat oneday races often ridden slightly different with rouleurs going all out more often than in a flat stage in a stagerace? Just so we don't end up messing with the points mechanics too much.
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2022/mghq.png
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2016/manager.png
pcmdaily.com/images/awards/2015/Manmanager.png
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2016/teamhq.png
 
Nemolito
OlegTinkov wrote:
PCM is never going to be perfect and the Mangame makes it even harder for PCM AI. But in the end instead of trying to fix everything by micro management, I'm in the just deal with it, sometimes crazy results are fun team.

Don't get me wrong if they are easy fixes for some problems I'm all in but just not overdo it is my advise.


I agree 100%. And I think what I proposed is one of those possible easy fixes for the yellow jersey problem.

@SotD: It remains to be seen how rouleurs would act if you only select one stage at a time. If it is the same, then no problem I think. If it is actually different and we see more rouleur attacks: also no problem I think Pfft But if this little fix would be implemented, that's a thing that can easily be tested quite quickly so people with rouleurs could know a bit better whether it is worth (for them) to send their rouleurs to sprinter stage races.

Of course, for a race starting with two flat stages, there is no such fix. You could switch a second and third stage for example on some occasions, but changing all of those would also be overdoing it I think, sometimes you just have got to embrace the randomness I guess.

Of course, like I said before, everything about that yellow jersey problem might not "count" anymore on other versions. But we'll burn that bridge when we get there Wink

Also, as said above, acceleration indeed seems incredibly important in sprints Smile
www.pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2020/newmember.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2021/mgreporter21.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2022/mgtoty.png
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2023/moty-cunego.png
 
roturn
Even though I still need to fully read through the latest posts, I am totally against changing the kind of racing in stage races and classics towards sprint stages in stage races as individual classics.

It might be doable with some excel files to later re-arrange the GC outcome but this always comes with extra work. Not only the excel work afterwards but also in the file transfer, DB settings, organization. And imo this is something where extra work must be reduced more than extended.

Right now there are several active reporters or better said, some reporters doing the work of 2-3 people with massive amount of reporting. Those really keep the game running. It does not necessarily mean that those will be able to do so in the future, so we shouldn`t plan to add some more work.

Organization wise the off seasons are hard to handle really and were last year mainly done by 3-4 managers and it`s pretty certrain that the following off seasons will need a lot more people to help out big time to come even close to the pace we used to have.

I agree that certrain things must be looked at AI wise and going to another game might be best (even though it`s not fully secured as far as I read if PCM19 and/or PCM20 are big improvements AI wise). In addition OVL stat adjustment, new calendar as usual, renewals, new riders are all time consuming things where help will be needed for sure as I won`t be able to do as much as in the past years but I know to really think things through, work into those kind of things is needed.

OVL adjustments usually need a season to "check" such as this year when things were made, over the season you see problems, which usually can be adjusted the year after to improve further. Now with a game change very likely/possible, last years OVL adjustment is basically needed to be re-done fully with another year of check due to a different game version. This is something where I will need help, in especially as I personally am not very well familiar with PCM19/20 and likely would make mistakes when considering different rider types. In especially as the MG DB is that big, that it`s not just 8-12 rider types but lots of combined riders such as Demare/Van Stayen/Kump, which are always hard to rate without being too much into one side or even riders that take profit from the game AI such as weirdos like high mo/low hi or midlevel mo/hi/tt kind of riders. Last year showed already that by "simple" formulas as 4-5 years ago you can`t make it fair enough for all kind of riders, so that a lot of extra formulas were needed to adjust specific stat combinations, which would need to be further adjusted to get some more things a bit more right, e.g. the Lopez/Beltran issue with OVL/stat comparison.

Having a OVL based on game performances/scored points might be an idea, which though would need time and most important is something incredibly difficult in years of a game change as things might change heavily and would make the following season very unfair here and there.
Similar it would be almost impossible to make for riders that were FAs or badly planned the year before, so not really something that can be added to the MG I think.

That said, last years formulas for over/underperformances already took note to this issue and fixed it here and there.
 
cunego59
Ulrich Ulriksen wrote:
So a few thoughts:

@SotD - I report mostly on PT but obviously follow CT so I have a pretty good view on both. I think Pro Tour spints are better and less weird because (1) there are far less sprinters and their stats are more spread and (2) There aren't that many sprinter only GC races. So I think if you only follow mostly PT you get a somewhat rosier view.

To be fair, this does point to the fact that the yellow jersey problem is at best another expression of how weird and random sprints especially at CT level are anyway. If it was an inherent problem, you'd see it at the PT level, too. Arguably, the evidence is pretty significant at CT level, but to say that there are more such random occurences in an environment that is in and of itself more random and also has more opportunities to spit out these random results is a bit circular imo. Like, even in bbl's tests, which are one stage settings, someone like Reinhardt who has been easily the most consistent sprinter this season at times ends up outside of the Top 10, and the riders that were hit with the yellow jersey curse sometimes were guys like Ismael Kip or Lobato del Valle, who I've not noticed as super reliable overall.

I'll do some testing later this week with sprint races one stage at a time, both to see if sprinters are more reliable and to get a feel for how much extra work it would be to put everything together (I tend to agree with roturn that it'll be a bit more than just 1 minute of Excel stuff, but we'll see).

However, I do think that even if we get a bit more realistic results, it should be noted that we give up some other pieces of realism. Like never seeing any rider in any leader shirt at all. And the KoM thing was mentioned already, but in my opinion, that's one of the random things we should embrace the most. The couple of random KoM jerseys my Rwandan neo-pros got this year were some of my greatest moments and to just wave them away saying they're random anyway, teams shouldn't count on those points, just doesn't sit right with me.
 
Nemolito
Like I said earlier, obviously sprint AI is very flawed in general on pcm18 (don't know about other versions), but according to me the yellow jersey problem is a problem on itself. So to conclude what I think about it (you won't hear me about it anymore, as I don't think I have anything else to add except for what i will say in the next bullet points - but of course if someone doesn't understand what I meant I'll gladly try to explain it):

- If you say it will take a lot of time for one of those solutions I proposed to implement, I don't agree. There can be found quick ways, such as simply giving top ten the points in green they get awarded now, and then have some kind of ranking quite quickly and accurately (for example)
- If you say it would be a shame to implement solution #1 and therefore "losing" KoM, I definitely understand you. But for me personally, overcoming that stupid problem of the GC lead is more important - as there would only be no KoM in like those four/five stage races. But that's a personal thought of course, and as I just said I definitely understand how those few random KoM's can mean a lot to some people (including me, who's hoping for those points in sprinter stage races Smile )
- If you say there will still be random sprints and stupid results, of course I agree. But just the fact that you know your/a sprinter will not sprint because of leading the GC is reason enough for me personally to try to find a rather easy change. I personally would care more about having a chance at a decent sprint from my sprinter when I know he's leading the GC virtually than see him wearing the yellow jersey and know he will not give a flying fuck.
- I don't agree that it doesn't happen in PT, as I have included in my previous post, also for the reason there are less chances of it happening because of fewer two flat stages after each other/sprint stage races.

Opinions differ, and if most of you don't feel the same about solving the problem as I do then so be it, I won't hold any grudge against anyone Pfft Like I said, just trying to help, as - in addition to other AI problems - that "solvable" problem has made "reporter-me" quite annoyed several times Smile
www.pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2020/newmember.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2021/mgreporter21.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2022/mgtoty.png
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2023/moty-cunego.png
 
baseballlover312
To be clear, I was selecting a single GT for my tests every time, and there were no rouleur attacks in the second half of the race in any trial, so I don't think that would fix anything anyway. It seems to be the same as a full stage race's AI.

Indeed, it looks like acceleration is as important if not more than sprint in this version. I don't think that in itself is a problem, it's just that we were told ACC would matter less before we started using PCM 18 (something which has played out on every other terrain). Now you may not even sprint despite having the highest sprint stat in the peloton.

The weird thing to me is the the game:

1.) Still generates these guys as sprinters in career
2.) Still places them as sprinters on the favorites list

So if they're acting as rouleur's, the game is doing it secretly - and randomly. As Ulrich pointed out, it seems AKA went from being a rouleur to a sprinter between trials of the exact same scenario, with the same stats and startlist. There was no correlation at all.

I can do a quick stage race test of the yellow jersey curse later today if I have time.
RIP Exxon Duke, David Veilleux, Double Feature, and Monster Energy
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2016/avatar.png
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2019/funniest.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2020/funniest.png
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2020/forumthread.png
i.imgur.com/VCXYUyF.png
i.imgur.com/4osUjkI.png
 
SotD
The ACC is definately playing a smaller part in the game than with PCM 15, but it may not be the scenario for sprinters indeed. But the ACC does play a part in the finale of other races aswell I think. That would explain why Lecuisinier is winning difficult HI finishes despite having 75HI. He does have a pretty solid ACC, much like Herklotz (Also last year before the training). Same basically applies for Koretzky who isn't a top puncheur, but have a very high ACC. This could be one of the explanations for why De Bie and Bakelants isn't performing all that well. They don't have bad ACC, but compared to the top puncheurs around them - they do.

Riders like Phinney and Lecuisinier win way more than Madrazo, which could again be something regarding the ACC. An issue riders like Kritskiy, Tenorio and to a part Haig also suffers a bit from. All of which get good GC results, but hardly enough stage succes compared to how strong they are.

Looking at the sprints (I have seen), riders like Lo Cicero, Guerao, Vanderbiest, Kristoff, Avelino does tend to perform worse than Groenewegen, Manninen, Boeckmans, Guardini or even Carsi (from time to time).

I am aware that other things play a huge role - much like random positioning, random trainsucces, random sprint start etc., but over the course of a season there might be some truth to it.

Looking at the top 15 sprinters in the PT (cleared of van Stayen, Demare, Bewley etc.)

1 John Degenkolb 84SPR 81ACC
2 Eduard Grosu 83 SPR 80ACC
3 Bryan Coquard 84SPR 83ACC
4 Peter Kennaugh 82SPR 81ACC
5 Dan Holloway 79SPR 81ACC
6 Dylan Groenewegen 82SPR 81ACC
7 Jonas Ahlstrand 83SPR 82ACC
8 Leigh Howard 82SPR 79ACC
9 Sam Harrison 78SPR 81ACC
10 Hsuan Ping Hsu 79SPR 79ACC
11 Tomohiro Hayakawa 79SPR 79ACC
12 Artem Samolenkov 81SPR 79ACC
13 Davide Appolonio 81SPR 78ACC
14 Emiliano Contreras 78SPR 80ACC
15 Ingus Eislers 80SPR 76ACC

At PT level there are 19 sprinters with 80+SPR. Out of those 6 have also got 80+ACC. You find these sprinters all in top 7 with only Dan Holloway mixing it with his 79SPR 81ACC.

Of the 13 remaining 80+ SPR riders with 79 or less in ACC only 4 find themselves in the top 15. Those sprinters seem to mix it up fairly evenly with riders at 78-79SPR but with 79+ ACC. Riders like Romain Vanderbiest 82SPR 77ACC, Danny van Poppel 81SPR, 78ACC, Sondre Holst Enger 81SPR 78ACC, Giacomo Nizzolo 80SPR 79ACC, Moreno Moser 80SPR 79ACC, Cameron Meyer 80SPR 76ACC and Matthew Goss 80SPR 75ACC isn't on the list, while there is room for the likes of Holloway, Harrison and Contreras instead.

Only 2 riders with less than 79ACC have made it to the list:
13 Davide Appolonio 78ACC
15 Ingus Eislers 76ACC

Obviously it isn't the entire truth as it also revolves around planning and luck, but the numbers seem pretty evensided to me... I have no clue if this is also the case in the lower divisions, but I would expect it to be somewhat true. So in that regard sprint results (over a season) haven't changed drastically from PCM 15. Only the leadouts and consistency seem to be very different.
pcmdaily.com/images/mg/Awards2022/mghq.png
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2016/manager.png
pcmdaily.com/images/awards/2015/Manmanager.png
pcmdaily.com/files/Awards2016/teamhq.png
 
quadsas
From the vote thread - if we switch to PCM20, there will need to be something done about ridiculous breakaways. From just playing, even with my own input, some breaks get 20+ minute gaps and finish so far ahead that GC or classic is easily won by the group itself. And it wasn't a one time thing, but also it's not too common an occurance, but it does happen. I figure if MG DB would also have an issue with it, it's probably only fixable by reporters using their own judgement and redoing the stage
deez
 
Ollfardh
quadsas wrote:
reporters using their own judgement and redoing the stage


That's a big no from me.
Changed my sig, this was getting absurd.
 
Jump to Forum:
Login
Username

Password



Not a member yet?
Click here to register.

Forgotten your password?
Request a new one here.
Latest content
Screenshots
And the winner is Cunego!
And the winner is Cunego!
PCM12: General Screenshots
Fantasy Betting
Current bets:
No bets available.
Best gamblers:
bullet fighti... 18,676 PCM$
bullet df_Trek 17,674 PCM$
bullet Marcovdw 15,745 PCM$
bullet jseadog1 13,752 PCM$
bullet baseba... 10,539 PCM$

bullet Main Fantasy Betting page
bullet Rankings: Top 100
ManGame Betting
Current bets:
No bets available.
Best gamblers:
bullet Ollfardh 21,990 PCM$
bullet df_Trek 15,820 PCM$
bullet Marcovdw 15,200 PCM$
bullet jseadog1 13,700 PCM$
bullet baseball... 7,432 PCM$

bullet Main MG Betting page
bullet Get weekly MG PCM$
bullet Rankings: Top 100
Render time: 0.49 seconds