PCM.daily banner
15-12-2024 12:39
PCM.daily
Users Online
· Guests Online: 29

· Members Online: 1
Booker

· Total Members: 162,068
· Newest Member: franshizi_fssn
View Thread
PCM.daily » PCM.daily's Management Game » [Man-Game] Discussion
 Print Thread
redordead's 2023 PCT prediction
Fabianski
Oops, apparently I only intended to comment on this after getting back from vacation, but then forgot to submit... sorry for being late Embarassed

I'm definitely not surprised by most of your predictions. I just compared it to mine - we have 11 teams where we differ by 0 or 1 spots, and 17 with a difference of up to 3 spots. So I'll mainly comment on those where we disagree a little more Wink

I see the biggest difference in our assessment of Team UBS, which I can see promoting while you have them outside the Top 10. I guess I'm a bit biased by them being a Swiss team, while you write you don't love any of their riders. I do actually like Buchmann, with the wage obvoiusly being his major downside, though. Spengler's backups have been slightly bumped year after year, and I think he's gotten more consistent lately - at least I can see him score pretty well (also thanks to the big support you also noticed). Van Asbroeck and Schelling could still be solid despite their declines - and they still have one of the division's top TTT outfits, which could be worth quite some points.
I do agree however that the lack of a proper rebuild this year could (and probably will) hurt them later on.

The other team I can see in the Top 10 and you don't is Tryg. I think that - well, I'm actually afraid that - Démare will dominate the division, and lead them inside the Top 10 singlehandedly. Summerhill should still be strong enough to be a Top 5 cobbler in PCT. I don't like the rest of the roster that much, but if Schlegel turns out to be a better fit for PCT than for CT, he could be a good scorer. Kron, Rodenberg, Norsgaard don't have an extremely well-rounded skillset, but should score well. Hoelgaard is known as a strong performer, and Seibeb pulled off some really strong results for P:A. But I agree that if Démare has too many DUC-like races, they aren't completely safe.

In the category "4 spots lower", we also have Bralirwa. I guess we agree on the leaders being pretty strong, but I probably value the rest of the team a tad higher. Most importantly, they have significantly improved their TTT unit - and if Izagirre isn't held back by his inferior backups, they could be having a great season. But yeah, you see, we're talking about differences of 4 spots, so we still see them in a similar region ^^

Let's take a look at the differences the other way round then, teams you have 4+ spots higher than I do. The most notable difference there is Popo4Ever, which you have 6 places higher. As you write, Padun and Beltran will obviously be their biggest scorers by far - and I don't see that much behind them to be honest. Prevar has declined and already struggled last year, Taaramäe and Pluchkin have really measly backups now - but at least there's some really good depth. And if they continue to get some Varga magic (still ridiculous that a non-punchy non-sprinter finishes 2nd in TDU), you could indeed be right with that 8th place.

For Xero, I absolutely agree on your assessment of their leaders, and that someone needs to step up if they are to promote. With your 5th place prediction, you think someone will - I think it won't happen, so that's the main difference I guess. And I also don't like that much that none of their leaders really can TT, as you can't avoid all the TT-heavy races in PCT.

So, who's left? 2 teams, Lampre going first. I agree that Turgis, Meurisse and Daniel look great - and Dzama has already shown a whole lot of magic in TDU, so he could be a big contributor I didn't really expect for them. However, even more so than for Xero, I really don't like their lack of TTing - not in PCT. Even though they'll likely finish higher than some people think (at least they got higher than you or me though last year), I'm not quite sure if Top 10 is on the table with the cobbles competition having grown stronger.

And the final team with a bigger than 3 spots difference is mine. I'll definitely take that 7th place - I'm hoping for an outcome in that region, but didn't dare putting us that high Wink
Whereas I might have the riders it takes to get a PCT Top 10, I might be lacking the (planning) experience to get the right riders to ride in the right races. TDU already was a partial failure with all of Schmid, Theuns and Bol present (and only one of them performing), so I have to hope my plans work out better in other races. I'd be happy with a Top 15, but Top 10 would obviously be nicer still Smile


Thanks a lot for taking so much time to do this prediction, it was a lot of fun reading it!
 
Jump to Forum:
Login
Username

Password



Not a member yet?
Click here to register.

Forgotten your password?
Request a new one here.
Latest content
Screenshots
TdF - Thibaut Pinot Wins Polka-Dot Jersey
TdF - Thibaut Pinot Wins Polka-Dot Jersey
PCM12: General Screenshots
Fantasy Betting
Current bets:
No bets available.
Best gamblers:
bullet fighti... 18,576 PCM$
bullet df_Trek 17,574 PCM$
bullet Marcovdw 15,645 PCM$
bullet jseadog1 13,752 PCM$
bullet baseba... 10,539 PCM$

bullet Main Fantasy Betting page
bullet Rankings: Top 100
ManGame Betting
Current bets:
No bets available.
Best gamblers:
bullet Ollfardh 21,890 PCM$
bullet df_Trek 15,720 PCM$
bullet Marcovdw 15,100 PCM$
bullet jseadog1 13,700 PCM$
bullet baseball... 7,432 PCM$

bullet Main MG Betting page
bullet Get weekly MG PCM$
bullet Rankings: Top 100
Render time: 0.18 seconds